Antelope Island
by tarohrer

Comment:
Oh no - this just too darn lovely to have a horizon line like that!! It's not just a little crooked, it's a LOT crooked. Even if that's the way it is in reality (which I don't think it is since the verticals in the reflection line up perfectly when I straighten the horizon), it throws the photo off - at least for this person. Would have been in my top three easily, but I can't. 9 or 10 is a generous 7. Everything else is stunning, but you missed that one critical detail.

tunnel to Wonderland
by clickodak

Comment:
Great colors and lines. Only critique is that you might want to do a touch of vertical perspective correction to get the vertical lines running parallel to the right edge (bump the bottom about +2 or 3). Or is that the top? Just noticed the perspective change. Nicely done.

Swoosh
by insteps

Comment:
I'd give you an extra point if I knew you managed this without making them stop or know that you were shooting this.

Tragopogon dubius
by undieyatch

Comment:
Bokeh'd dark lines detract from the subject, which is otherwise extremely well processed.

"Let the wild rumpus start!"
by chazoe

Comment:
Feels a touch too dark light-wise, not subject-wise - that's dark enough. ;)

Minneapolis Central Library
by Elaine

Comment:
Nice photo but I'm not digging the processing or the lean to the right along the left edge. Handled differently this could be stunning. 6 as is.

Pastoral
by sfalice

Comment:
Nice colors but is extremely awkward compositionally. I want to twist it hard left or right, just so long as it doesn't stay the way it is.

Guardians of Light
by colorcarnival

Comment:
How I wish people would just get out of your pictures.

The Trolly Diner and Ice Cream Shoppe (Philadelphia, PA)
by mefnj

Comment:
Like the idea of the old photo frame look. A little too much foreground for me.

King of the Forest
by wejna

Comment:
Your boosting the sharpness and structure of the Moose needs to be balanced with what it does with the rest of the photo. Layer masks and control points (depending on software) are your friends here. As is, you can't even add blur to fix it because you've over-defined your tree trunks. 5 that could have been much more.