the still light
by pauleeart

Comment by JulietNN:
Hi from the Critique Club,

You asked for your shot to have an in depth comment from a member of the Critique Club.

I do not think that this is going to be a very in depth comment as there is not a lot to comment on.

Gorgeous!!!!!!!!

I gave this an 8 in voting and here are the reasons why it was not a 10. The size of the shot is fairly small, remember you can go up to 640 on one side in basic. And that was the only reason

This is a wonderful shot, your processing is fantastic.

Well done

the still light
by pauleeart

Comment by JimiRose:
Ooo the low res really kills this shot - I'm sure it looks stunning as a big picture.

the still light
by pauleeart

Comment by hesitant:
shame this doesn't look bigger cos it's great

the still light
by pauleeart

Comment by oldbimmercoupe:
hits the challenge on the nose - terrific capture. not a fan of this crop - even if its a pano. nice tonality.

the still light
by pauleeart

Comment by Niecy:
This is gorgeous. Love the dramatic sky and the detail.

the still light
by pauleeart

Comment by SoulJance:
nice BW conversion. If the boat was not in the centre of the shot your photo would have had more impact,

sweet death
by pauleeart

Comment by JulietNN:
HI from the CC Club,

This is an amazing shot, reminds me of something i have seen before, just not sure where or what.

I love the tones and colours you have going on here. The pig is sublime, not sure what the other white things are, they sort of look like eyeballs gone wrong.

I am presuming that you laid the cloth on the pig, if you did it really makes this image surreal and full of impact. It almost seems like it is being tucked into bed.

The only thing i would change in this shot is a closer crop, make a tube with your hand and look through it and you will see a closer crop that sometimes works and sometimes doesn't.

Even though the pig is dead or very fast asleep, i do get a sense of peace from this shot.

I am certainly looking forward to see a LOT more work from you, this is a stunning image

Message edited by author 2009-08-05 10:58:34.

sweet death
by pauleeart

Comment by posthumous:
btw, I just want you to know that I loved this and that's why I put that strange blue image on it.