Perfect Circle
by PSUBecker

Comment:
Pretty yellow flower! Good focus and color. Your title says to me "tight circle", but the flower isn't a tight circle, even if it basically circular - challenge accepted, but I'd suggest a different title. The cropping cuts off the circular pattern even more. As much as I like this flower, the best I can go is a 6. Rob the Swash

Round in nature
by DragonBro

Comment:
Nice marigold. It's sort of round, the nitpickers are going to have a field day with you. The image seems very small, so it's hard to make out the details. The leaves at the middle distance to the ground seem strongly in focus (more than the flower). Good color! 6 Rob the Swash

- Metalic bubble -
by Anastasia

Comment:
Very cool coloration! Love the detail in the bubble! A little bit of grain in the foreground, but the amazing colors distract my eyes away from it. 10 Rob the Swash

I Have Round Spots On My Wings
by Gallatin

Comment:
Love butterflies! This must be some distance relative to the Blue Morphious. Great details!!! 10 Rob the Swash

Eye see you!
by wetland

Comment:
Very nice shot! Intense details!!!! EAsy 10! Rob the Swash

Round-Head
by Nazgul

Comment:
I'm sure this is a wild hair style, but I can't see most of it (much is in the dark). You've got some interesting coloration with the lighting, but the subject isn't very sharp and his head seems a bit grainy. 5 Rob the Swash

Flame On
by Stewan

Comment:
The focus seems pretty good, but the heavy effect makes it difficult to see, esp. the lower part of the circle. This is an "artsy" shot, so I try to be extra kind, but frankly, I don't really care for this effect (sorry, must be MY bad). 5 Rob the Swash

moon rise
by medic391

Comment:
I like the clouds, it creates a neat effect, but it seems like the camera tried to focus on those clouds as the moon isn't as sharp. Must have been the last day of the challenge (I did mine the day before and the moon wasn't quite full). 5 Rob the Swash

Canada's Horse
by Morgan

Comment:
This has been the toughest to score so far. The shot of the horse and rider are wonderfully sharp and colorful, but....the only roundness I see is your frame, please clue me in if I'm wrong, but the frame is an artificial add-on to the photo, not the photo itself. 6 Rob the Swash

Zero spot editing. How?
by kiwiness

Comment:
Extremely cool! Very well thought out shot! Damn good!!!