The Spearman
by flip89

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club
By Inspzil

Composition - This is a really nice composition as it is. The only thing I can see here is that its tight in the frame. There seems to be a little bit of the pole showing behind it but its not a huge distraction.

Technical - To me, this seems to be where all the problems fall. The sky has some funky things going on that look like the results from oversaturating. It could also be some noise from the longer exposure. It seems like the exposure might have been just a little too long. Shortening that would've cut down the hot spots and maybe even a little of the background noise. I'm still trying to figure out what the blue line is right above the base of the statue.

Overall - I'm disappointed that this didn't do better than it did, even with some of its shortcomings. I thought it was a better photo than 5.0 but I guess I'm just one voter. Take care, good luck and all that stuff - Bob

Sign of Old
by Rgarcia

Comment:
Great toning. The color of this sign is really authentic like an old photo. Great shot. I think this one should do pretty well 8

Not In This Weather They Don't!
by basia03

Comment:
some funky effects on the heads and necks of the flamingos. There may be some oversharpening or compression issues involved. The title sure says a lot too.

School sign from children's perspective
by Pep Ventosa

Comment:
The sky is too blue on this one. The saturation is too much. From what I can see its breaking up from oversaturation. Good use of the rule of thirds in terms of where the sign is.

Sunset
by faidoi

Comment:
This is pretty good. The colors were pretty good. Something went wrong though. It's breaking up a bit at the top probably due to saturation. MIght be a little oversaturated. Its a nice shot still. 7

One of the Few Remaining Mail Pouch Tobacco Barn Signs
by dirtkahuna

Comment:
There are one of these signs on a barn a few miles from my house. I see it driving home every day. Its in a little better shape than this one. Interesting shot, but I really don't see it as a road sign as much as an advertisement.

sign in the sky
by darcy

Comment:
way too much saturation. The color in the sky is cool, but its breaking apart from oversaturation.

WATCH OUT -- BLIND SPOT
by RUEDISCHMUTZ

Comment:
This is an interesting picture. I don't know if that qualifies it as a sign, but its better than most of the other pictures in this challenge. 7

A very scenic drive
by leskataus

Comment:
One of the better ones I've seen. Good colors. The shadows are just a little heavy. I like the color saturation, but I think a little more exposure would've done you well for this shot. Good work 8

Left Turn(ed)
by GP

Comment:
This looks a bit phallic to me. What the hell does it have to do with roadsigns? I guess I get a chuckle out of it. It does seem a bit strange to me though. Maybe I'm the only one skewed enough to see it that way. Or maybe not....