Broken childhood
by json

Comment:
Spooky image, well set up and executed

A roof full of sky
by PaulE

Comment:
Cool subject, there just seeems to be too many elements and they're distracting from the core message. It took me ages to see that the building is roofless and still cannot see that for sure

Break Away
by Canadian_eh

Comment:
Is it broken, I just can't quite see enough of the subject to tell but I really really liek the colours, textures and composition of this and would happily hang it on the wall.

Shattered
by Sammie

Comment:
Very broken, well found. The impact needed to score high isn't there yet and I'm trying to figure out how you could get that. Perhaps it's that it looks too lively and happy with nice bright colours - I don't know. Sorry I can't offer a solution.

Cracked
by bryanbrazil

Comment:
This is a great abstract. The cnetre of the crack being right on thirds is just terrific.

Forever Still
by ltaylor

Comment:
Beautiful sunset and setting, it just doesn't look broken from back here. We only have the title to give us a hint

No Vacancy
by Cam

Comment:
I can't decide about this. The B&W treatment is really cool as is the lighting affect of the sky looking like a halo .. perhaps it's that it is very centred that subtracts frm the wow-factor. Will come back and review

I Didn't Do It
by shabbychic

Comment:
Cat pix usually get a thumbs-down from me ... but not this one, the setup and then the cat's 'expression' are priceless

What Once Was
by KarenNfld

Comment:
Taht's really good. The leading lines of the boat work for the composition. The lighting and colours just work so well too. Of all things the yellow rocks really add something to this

Broken Window
by artvet

Comment:
Awesome subject, nice use of thirds for the window. I haven't decided on the B&W treatment yet but I have to mention the lack of straightening. The vertical of the window shoud be either vertical or way tilted, not just a degree and a half off like this. It gives the impression that ti's a sloppy job or that you don't care - neither of which are true I'm sure.