what a day!
by mariuca

Comment:
I am guessing the guy on the bike is the silhouette and subject of the photograph but he is just a bit to small and insignificant for me to notice. My eye is drawn down the road and between the building to the "light at the end of the tunnel".

Living Outside the Spotlight
by Lydia

Comment:
The people in the background are a silhouette but the subject is not. I really wanted the subject to be the silhouette, it looks more like you took this photo and then realized "I got the perfect shoehorn"

A Horse is a Horse of Course
by WonderDude

Comment:
The horse has to much detail in it for me as a silhouette. The definition for silhouette is "the dark shape and outline of someone or something visible against a lighter background, especially in dim light" and for me a sharp or outline has no detail and is just a that.......a shape that from that shape I can determine what it is.

nesting
by NiallOTuama

Comment:
Great abstract but I am not sure what I am looking at so can't really decide if it is a silhouette or not.

Failing to fall
by Paul

Comment:
A little to much detail in the subject but a very interesting photograph. Would have preferred it without the texture tho.

Longing for spring
by hajeka

Comment:
Really would have preferred the flowers to be in full silhouette.

it's all over but the crying
by mefnj

Comment:
While I could be wrong but this looks like a shadow of a wine bottle and not a silhouette. I am still trying to decide if (to me) it meets the criteria for a silhouette. That aside.......it is an interesting and engaging photograph but it is more about the texture then anything else.

We will become silhouettes.
by odriew

Comment:
Not a fan of the texture you added and the bird over his head is distracting.

paint it black
by PennyStreet

Comment:
A really interesting photograph but a silhouette is a dark shape or outline against a brighter background and this is more or less black on black. Great execution on the photograph but for me it is not a silhouette.

Unside down - fill the glass
by pgirish007

Comment:
Very interesting take on the challenge. I am still trying to decide if it is a silhouette as the shape is not really meaningful like a person or a dog or bird etc. Nice photograph tho.