Rustic Recipe
by tvsometime

Comment:
Good choice edit wise. For some reason I can't tell what is in the bowl behind the tomato. I may have tried to find containers for the oil, cheese and pepper that showcased the item rather than the container. You have a cool rustic feel to the edit but then some containers that come right from the grocery store. Kind of breaks the feel.

Super-Moist Banana Bread (Still Baking)
by essay

Comment:
Love banana bread. I may have gone with a bit more in focus, having that middle loaf pretty sharp with the other two OOF. My eye desires to see the texture of the loaf better. My mouth desires to eat the loaf. ;)

Meet Joe Black
by adigitalromance

Comment:
Pleasing colors and focus. I think you could have improved the impact of the image by positioning and cropping the image to be a bit more balanced. The circle of the cup is good, but the clipped handle is a bummer. Positioned so the handle is in and balanced along with the saucer being positioned in the frame similarly on all four corners would have made this a stronger image. Now to go refill my cup. ;)

Hey Mom! I'm making cookies for you!
by vawendy

Comment:
This is pretty funny and a decent out of the box entry. Bumping up 1.

top of the food chain
by jmritz

Comment:
I appreciate out of the box, artistic and even blurry images (look at my fave list), but this one isn't doing a whole lot for me. Slightly curious as to what it is but only slightly.

Pininyahang Manok
by LandzEnca

Comment:
This is one plate in the challenge that I would be very interested in trying. I love chicken wings and this prep looks spicy and tasty. Photographically it's a bit flat. I desire to see more of the dish in the picture, and the whites and brightness to be bumped up a bit to really give the colors in your dish the canvas to pop. Just a bit too tight and not bright enough for me. Yet i am still going to bump it up 1 as i was probably a bit hard on it the first time through voting.

Mixing Chocolate Milk
by BuddyBaum

Comment:
I think you might have an interesting base idea here but it's execution leaves it in the "meh" category for me.

Cream puff
by BrennanOB

Comment:
Yeah baby, love a good cream puff. I may have gone with a square crop on this and gotten rid of some of the upper background. Not sure if it really adds anything to the image. Probably would have tweaked the cream and made it a bit less yellow and more white. The image overall has a slight yellow cast on my monitor. Bumping up 1 as I was probably a bit harsh the first time through.

Ham Stock for Split Pea Soup
by Bear_Music

Comment:
Interesting image. Sure doesn't make me hungry looking at it, but the colors and textures are intriguing none the less. Bumping up a bit as I was probably too harsh on it the first go through.

Panzanella Salad
by LN13

Comment:
Had to look up what panzanella was.Thought it looked like toasted bread cubes. Betcha this is quite yummy. Pleasing image overall. Good use of bokehed props. Has a slight tilt that is a bit odd but not a big issue. Bumping up 1.