Great Central Railway
by Marston

Comment:
Meets Challenge: 1/1
Lighting: 1/2
Focus: 1/2
Creativity: 1/2
Aesthetics: 2/3

I like the dirction and flow of this photo quite a bit. I'd love to see a photo with shadows cast at an angle, early morning or later in the day. Railroad tracks always offer such interesting lines, I love seeing them with interesting shadows.

Gods Perspective
by Len Scap

Comment:
Meets Challenge: 1/1
Lighting: 1/2
Focus: 1/2
Creativity: 1/2
Aesthetics: 2/3

Ocean Mist
by marbo

Comment:
Meets Challenge: 1/1
Lighting: 2/2
Focus: 2/2
Creativity: 1/2
Aesthetics: 2/3

Sunset in New York, GWB
by MPRPRO

Comment:
Meets Challenge: 1/1
Lighting: 1/2
Focus: 1/2
Creativity: 1/2
Aesthetics: 1/3

For me this photo is okay, but could have been better. It appears as though the camera was simply tilted, and results in a diagonal perspective. I like the photo overall, but would have appreciated the lines of the bright better if it were straight with the horizon. The colours seem a bit washed out in areas as well, perhaps a bit higher aperture and a bit longer shutterspeed.

Joy
by pacpinto

Comment:
Meets Challenge: 1/1
Lighting: 0/2
Focus: 1/2
Creativity: 1/2
Aesthetics: 1/3

The idea is good, it does a good job of identifying the title. The subject is not lit properly however, and it detracts from the photo quite a bit. Her entire face and arm are shadowed. I'd like to see this photo with some fill in flash. Don't be afraid to use flash outdoors, it will remove harsh shadows under the eyes, nose, lips and chin in mid day sun. It will also help in situations like this, where the sky is bright, but the subject itself looks as though they are in a shadow.

Hoop
by walrus451

Comment:
Meets Challenge: 1/1
Lighting: 0/2
Focus: 1/2
Creativity: 1/2
Aesthetics: 1/3

The idea is okay, but there's some hazing/noise around almost all the edges. The sky also has some noise in it overall, and the actual net/hoop itself is rendered flat due to the lighting. I like the angle and concept, but perhaps using flash either bounced off a white card or softened with some tissue would bring out some of the muted details and make them sharper.

Boats at Sunset
by Miss Taterbug

Comment:
Meets Challenge: 1/1
Lighting: 1/2
Focus: 1/2
Creativity: 1/2
Aesthetics: 1/3

rush hour
by tate

Comment:
Meets Challenge: 1/1
Lighting: 1/2
Focus: 1/2
Creativity: 1/2
Aesthetics: 2/3

Piazza Duomo, Catania (Italy)
by gipomontesanto

Comment:
Meets Challenge: 1/1
Lighting: 2/2
Focus: 2/2
Creativity: 1/2
Aesthetics: 2/3

Overpass Construction Under Full Moon
by cogerox

Comment:
Meets Challenge: 1/1
Lighting: 2/2
Focus: 1/2
Creativity: 1/2
Aesthetics: 1/3

Love the light on the rocks. Morning I am guessing.