The mother
by greslizzz

Comment:
Man, is either you are really out of the theme by a long shot with this one, either I do not understand it... I put here a 1... the picture is good though, but I will discourage not meeting the theme, sorry.

Rhythmic Curves
by DigiFotoBuddy

Comment:
Maybe with a black background?

Strength in repetition
by whatsthatbeeping

Comment:
Nice shot. Heavy contrast ads to diagonal. Subject almost perfectly framed, and the sky has nice blue. Had it been more techncally acurate I would mark it a 9-10 but:

1- slightly out of focus
2- to few shades of blue in the sky showing as artifacts
3- could have waited till the cloud disappeared

7 :( try to remake it in PS and add it to your prtfolio

Roof Wave
by jent

Comment:
Out of focus, lacks apeal... 4 :(

Curves
by stare_at_the_sun

Comment:
Nice image. Can't really connect to the theme though.
I would give a 7 as a standalone but can't gie more than 5 as a challenge submission. please dont' take personally

"Right as Rain"
by scared_of_the_dark

Comment:
This is great. If it was after me, this would be the winner. We shall wait and see...

Curiosity Killed The Cat
by naruto_fanboy

Comment:
Color/exposure/contrast: 0/2 bluecast, oveexposed
Focus/sharpness/DOF: 0/2 out of focus
Idea/creativity: 2+++/2
Theme: 2+++/2
Framing/appeal: 0/2 not a very appealing photo
TOTAL:4+++ but I'll mark 6 just for the laughs I had. Best Theme connection so far. Lool

"Birds of a Feather Flock Together" - Like Associates with Like
by AlexSaberi

Comment:
Color/exposure/contrast: 2/2 perfect. i like the color palette
Focus/sharpness/DOF: 1.5/2 good sharpness, and dof but focus should e on the lower deers not the back ones
Idea/creativity: 2/2 2 just for the fact that is mighty hard to get near a herd of so many deers
Theme: 1/2 should use something else that meant the same as a title, birds is a little bit unappropriate, and the second one does not sound so melodic
Framing/appeal: 2/2 i like it!
TOTAL:8.5

Piss out the fire, call the dogs and lets go home!
by birkin

Comment:
Color/exposure/contrast: 2/2 perfect
Focus/sharpness/DOF: 1/2 sharpness not very good
Idea/creativity: 2/2 just for the fact that this could be someone's house burning although could be just a normal fire (in which case I would give a 1)
Theme: 0.5/2 not very fortunate chosen
Framing/appeal: 1.5/2 nicely framed, appealing, but sharpness takes some of the pleasure watching
TOTAL:7

Not playing with a full deck
by LalliSig

Comment:
Color/exposure/contrast: 2/2 perfect
Focus/sharpness/DOF: 2/2 perfect
Idea/creativity: 2/2 very creative
Theme: 0/2 the theme-title-picture are totally disconected. terrible.
Framing/appeal: 1.5/2 nice picture but I just can't get the chair and can't connect the hair drying with the background
TOTAL:7.5