Gone Fishing
by MattB

Comment:
Nice job at fish photography since this is very difficult to do. Aside from that, I don't see a very enticing shot. It's more snapshot-esque and the tail is cut off.

Naked Neon
by KaDi

Comment:
Excessively grainy. The subject (the sign) goes right up to the edge in the upper left and very close to it in the lower right. I feel that there shou;d be some space between the subject and the edge as this current composition feels cramped.

Finding neon where I can...
by ursulas

Comment:
The terry cloth "fish" and "rabbit" and "duck" are very creative. I like the lighting and composition. Very nice overall. But that, um, border has got to go. Way too distracting.

Like Giants
by Elemmennope

Comment:
I really like this one but it seems really grainy to me. :)

Shadow Dunes II
by Elemmennope

Comment:
I prefer this one over the other. The other shot has too many distractions in the sand itself like dead plant matter. This one seems relatively void of such imperfections. I also like the background better here with the water and the birds in V formation. Although it seems difficult to tell if the horizon is level due to the mountains and water, it looks level. I'd tinker around with levels and curves to maximize contrast and maybe clone out the odd bits and ends in the sand. One more suggestion: try this in b/w or some other duotone. Sometimes the best nature shots, or shots in general, look much better in b/w.

Otherwise, great shots and keep up the good work! I wish I had access to dunes like these but I have stuff like the Walt Disney Concert Hall, sheesh. :)

Old Port
by belette

Comment:
Nice contrast of old and new architecture to make your vanishing point. Colors seem bland and lack punch and depth.

St Kilda Pier at night
by mandyp

Comment:
The lamps seems to distract me from the main purpose of this image and so does the puddle with the bright highlights. Once I get past that, the vanishing point is apparent and executed nicely. Focus seems to be off a bit.

Country Road Take Me Home....
by Mona

Comment:
Interesting take on the challenge! I like this twist on the concept and I think it works very well. However, you seem to have over sharpened by quite a lot and it shows in the overprocessed highlights throughout the image as well as the unusually sharp edges of the tree leaves. Experiment with varying heights (vantage points) to see what works best vs only taking at standing eye level.

Countryscape
by GolferDDS

Comment:
Well cropped and implemented. I think it might have been more dramatic if you were a bit lower and closer to the fence therefore the fence coming from behind the camera, past the camera and far in front into the vanishing point. Focus seems a bit fuzzy, too.

Can't see the forest for the trees
by cwyou

Comment:
Such a shame that this photo is so poorly focused. I really liked the thumbnail and was excited to look at the full image. Contrast is also off and the right side and bottom could be cropped a bit more.