Unhinged
by ranout

Comment by Rankles:
Far too small, small images do not do well in challenges. Please use the full 640x640 we are allowed. Aside from that, nice tone,focus and good composition. Just a shame it's so damn small.

Unhinged
by ranout

Comment by docpjv:
unhelpful comment removed

Message edited by author 2005-10-05 06:27:35.

Unhinged
by ranout

Comment by gerdagrice:
This photo is a bit too small to be seen properly.

Unhinged
by ranout

Comment by Ivo:
Interesting concept but the photo is too small. The composition is good and the Sepia adds a nice effect.

Unhinged
by ranout

Comment by thatcloudthere:
Youl'l probably get marked down for the size of this photo as it's hard to get a good look at it...that being said, it looks like it could have been a great photo although I'm not too excited about the placement of the hinge in the frame. the composition seems to be lacking in this regard. otherwise, a great subject with great mood to it.

Unhinged
by ranout

Comment by miaminovice:
Nice photo, but too small. Increasing the file size might gain you some much deserved points.

Unhinged
by ranout

Comment by sidpixel:
I quite like this but I wish it was a bigger image

Unhinged
by ranout

Comment by snackwells:
Hi there. I'd like to spend some time and give you a detailed critique.

Challenge theme: Appropriate. Fits within the spirit of the challenge.

Technical details:
- Size: Inadequate. Please resize to 600-640 pixels in all future submissions.
- Focus: Appears to be satisfactory. Fine detail is present.
- Tonal range: Compressed. No tonal values in either extreme.
- Exposure: Adequate for given artistic presentation.

Artistic details: Your composition and framing works well here. The gritty duotone sets the mood. There's not enough pixels here to really give your photo the impact it deserves and can potentially impart.

Overall: This is a good effort which is unfortunately hampered by technical limitations imposed by the size of the entry.

Unhinged
by ranout

Comment by Dr.Confuser:
Please try to make your images bigger. It's hard to appreciate any detail this size.