Frame of Picture
by philipandc

Comment by photom:
I'm sorry, but your image does not grab me in any way. There's just not enough in focus.

Frame of Picture
by philipandc

Comment by Dr.Confuser:
Interesting choice of DOF. I like that. B&W works well. Composition is pretty good. But somehow, this doesn't hold my interest.

Frame of Picture
by philipandc

Comment by dipaulk:
I hesitate to make comments since I am obviously not an expert, but here goes: the photo meets the challenge and has an interesting focal point. It is just my opinion that a photo should be able to "stand alone" apart from the challenge (not sure that makes sense, in other words, it should be a good subject even if you don't know what challenge it was entered into). I felt that was where this photo was a little weak -- I couldn't see it having meaning apart from the challenge.

Frame of Picture
by philipandc

Comment by birdyblue:
Good idea but too blurry.

Frame of Picture
by philipandc

Comment by groggyfroggy:
A little too out of focus for my tastes. good luck

Frame of Picture
by philipandc

Comment by dcano:
Just my opinion but I feel the shallow dept of field just does not work for this image.
dc

Frame of Picture
by philipandc

Comment by artation:
To my eye, this seems to have DOF problems.

Frame of Picture
by philipandc

Comment by sfabio:
really nice, looks like it is in motion.

Frame of Picture
by philipandc

Comment by _wu_:
the DOF is bad here imho. I can't see any reason to make it that shallow.
unfortunately using DOF in a good way is VERY hard to master