Let's Roll !
by maessenger

Comment by mrsmaxsmart:
I am leaving a comment for everyone so no one will feel left out so here is yours...
work on lighting properly

Let's Roll !
by maessenger

Comment by deli:
the sharpening is obvious on the apple, the lighting is poor.

Let's Roll !
by maessenger

Comment by Zed Pobre:
Image is out of focus, seems slightly posterized, and has dark shadows that drop off too severely into black. The reflected highlight on the knife is also very harsh, and seems blown. The colors on the blade are somewhat pretty, but the colors on the handle are very odd, and the green at the left looks like fungus. Try a different angle to avoid the reflection, which is causing the extreme dynamic range hurting this image in both directions. If the title had been about the reflected light, drawing the interest to the colors, the image might have been more interesting, but as it is, it isn't really memorable, and the light just looks like an artifact of the reflection error. An apple and a knife on a counter alone isn't a very interesting image.

Base: 5
Technical: -2
Interest: -1
Emotion: +0
Bias: +0

Total: 2

Let's Roll !
by maessenger

Comment by JunieMoon:
Apple is not clear enough.

Let's Roll !
by maessenger

Comment by muggle_girl:
just a small pity about the glare on the knife

Let's Roll !
by maessenger

Comment by totaldis:
way too much noise and compression shades.

Let's Roll !
by maessenger

Comment by mpemberton:
Neat idea, meet your maker style. There is to much glare in the photo, it has to effects. First, you can see complete square pixel boxes where the apple surface becomes black. Second, it is causing some-kind of funny overload in the image wreaking havoc on the colours and lines. 5

Zoom in on the window
by maessenger

Comment by messerschmitt:
Gerry, not a brilliant score but a nice result anyway

the mainly nice comments should convince u to go on with this photography thing and surprise us some more with ur imagination
(but meanwhile don t u forget to work on that record dammit..bout time the 'world' should be aknowledged what a fine musician u are)
greetings
wil

Message edited by author 2005-05-04 04:49:05.

Zoom in on the window
by maessenger

Comment by TooCool:
Great concept, but you have a couple of minor flaws. Too many unneeded objects in the frame (lawn chairs and whatever is below the sink on the right. Also your subject needs much more light to make him the true focal point of the shot.
TC

Zoom in on the window
by maessenger

Comment by arsharif:
maybe you should have zoomed it more.