Late Afternoon Reflections
by micluinenburg

Comment by nlghttrain:
this is not doing anything special for me. It is a clean shot, but the composition does not jump out at me.

Late Afternoon Reflections
by micluinenburg

Comment by jomari:
Beautiful shot.

Late Afternoon Reflections
by micluinenburg

Comment by rick13601:
A nice photo and meets the challenge well.

Late Afternoon Reflections
by micluinenburg

Comment by JulietNN:
I like how the ice is edging in on the tree reflection.smooth curving ice into the twisty curving tree branches. Nice colours on the tree drifting into the darker blues to the edge of hte shot. well done

Untitled
by micluinenburg

Comment by lynnesite:
The pond scum gives it added appeal.

Untitled
by micluinenburg

Comment by doctornick:
Ewwwww! Interesting light. Tough subject to take an appealing photo of...

Untitled
by micluinenburg

Comment by JunieMoon:
Liked the way the foam forms rings around the bottle. I think it could have been better cropped. The rocks to the left really don't do much to enhance the photo. The water and the juncture of rocks just to the left of the bottle top are the best part of the image.

Untitled
by micluinenburg

Comment by tpoc:
more striking than the bottle is the pollution visible in the water. nicely composed.

Untitled
by micluinenburg

Comment by KarenNfld:
Interesting lines and textures here, the focus seems slightly off though.

untitled
by micluinenburg

Comment by SteveJ:
Greetings from the Critique Club:

The challenge was to take a photo that would convey 'Delicate' to the viewers and voters. In a strange way this ornamental cabbage just about does that. You have not included any information on processing, so I can't comment on how it may have altered the original. I am guessing that this is near enough straight out the camera, perhaps a bit of sharpening was used.
My biggest problem with your shot is the size, although not really small, it is not using the maximum permitted - 640x640. To create an impact, you need to get your photos to 640x640 and 150k to do well in challenges, you will suffer if you enter small photos. The cropping is very tight, but I assume that was to eliminate the soil that is just visible in the top right of the shot. Also, clean up the subject before shooting, the dead leaves do not add anything to the shot. The spot of water in the centre is distracting and either focus right in on it or get rid of it before taking your picture.
I like the fractal-like patterns created by the leaves and also the colouring, especially where the purple veins run into the green/blue. For a first effort this scored well and I am sure if you use size properly next challenge you will do well. I hope this is helpful and constructive.

Steve