Dumb Nurse
by derekleung

Comment by Yomi:
~~Critique Club Comment~~

COMPOSITION-
Composition is great in this. Nice work with the story and how you've laid everything out. Very interesting idea for this challenge. I can't think of anything better technically to change with this shot. I think that you've cropped it great and I like the diagonal letter layout. The pills are great.

BACKGROUND-
N/A, there really isn't much of a background other than the hint of the table. No clutterness on it.

CAMERA WORK-
Great DOF and lighting in this. Everything is clear.

DIGITAL PROCESSING-
No compression artifacts or noise. You've cropped this great and the levels are right on. I wonder if you could lighten it up just a bit.

MY OPINION-
Not many people understood this shot and voted you down. I was one that didn't understand and I gave you a 5. I understand now that I can read the comments and I think this shot is great. Very nice take on the challenge. I thought your camera work was great. Good job.

Dumb Nurse
by derekleung

Comment by GeneralE:
I can relate in several ways. I might have said "must be taken.." instead of "are to be..." and underlined the word "must" to make sure all those literal-minded voters saw how it met the challenge.

Dumb Nurse
by derekleung

Comment by catpixel:
What perfect printing! You must be a school teacher.

Dumb Nurse
by derekleung

Comment by kendall:
what a cool shot idea...i really love this. worth extra points +9 kendall

Dumb Nurse
by derekleung

Comment by LobsterClaws:
But I can't see the pills colors? I'm going to die!!!

Dumb Nurse
by derekleung

Comment by PTLParsons:
Technically good photo....BUT..you would at least expect the pills to be colored. What a poor time to do B & W. I know they said it didn't have to be blue, but just give a hint of blue. This is too far fetched of a hint, even for the most imaginative mind. I know you expected comments like this, and you got it. This has to be for a joke. At least give a yellow pills, green pills, and blue pills. I'm giving it a 3 because it is such a clear photo, otherwise it would be a 1. I really can't believe you did this. And yes I'll sign this. PTL 3 It is nice hand writing.

Dumb Nurse
by derekleung

Comment by nards656:
This is absolutely hilarious, and I'm voting it a 10 because it is entirely too creative. Excellent take on color blindness - although most CAN see blue - and the use of black and white. Good luck!

Dumb Nurse
by derekleung

Comment by Turbotech:
I do not get it.

Dumb Nurse
by derekleung

Comment by mediamst:
interesting

Dumb Nurse
by derekleung

Comment by Paige:
very funny. Well seen and executed.