Star gazer
by Caillie

Comment by KarenNfld:
A landscape and a starfish (a living creature) is not a still life, sorry.

Star gazer
by Caillie

Comment by TheStick:
One of my favorites in the challenge! Good subject, composition, coloring. Not 100% about the boarder though. Still a 10 from me!

Star gazer
by Caillie

Comment by hotpasta:
great wide angle shot

Lake at night
by Caillie

Comment by srdanz:
Watch your horizons...

Bubbling under the surface
by Caillie

Comment by ericwoo:
Hey there from the Critique Club

Congrats on your best scoring photograph to date. I like your choice of subjects here and your composition is terrific. This one fits the challenge very well, but its almost hard to recognize. While the focus is very crisp and the exposure is on, the animal moving through the water creates a distortion that would be very hard to overcome. This one would have gotten a 5 or 6 from me, so I think that it finished well. I think that this photo is about as good as it could be considering what you were working with. Nature isn't very easy to script, at least not when I try to do it. Nice work, and I'm sure that your scores will continue to climb.

Lake at night
by Caillie

Comment by ignite:
Too dark and noisy; nothing of interest to see. This would have been so much better if the water was more visible.

Lake at night
by Caillie

Comment by margiemu:
Simple and clean. Maybe a little more detail around the edge of the lake so that it's clear that it's a lake would have been better. I like the colors.

Lake at night
by Caillie

Comment by pamelasue:
noisy, but otherwise great concept ... love the stars ...

Lake at night
by Caillie

Comment by rkligman:
Finally, a sky pic that isn't all sky. Nice elements in the shot. - 8

Lake at night
by Caillie

Comment by lectrol:
A little underexposed. but i thinkit could do good.