Eyes Sq On
by redfig

Comment by PaulMdx:
Composition: Good
Technical: Excellent focus, lighting and border.
Meets challenge: Yes
Overall impression: Really good pic. 8

Eyes Sq On
by redfig

Comment by DougPaz:
I love the idea. I would like not quite as many reflections in the eye. It seems like it could be just a bit sharper as well. Perhaps take advantage of more of the alotted file size. Good shot.

Eyes Sq On
by redfig

Comment by thatguy:
Nice image. I like your idea. The image also has a good clearity. The detail of the eye really stands out. I like this image, good job.

Eyes Sq On
by redfig

Comment by KimInNB:
Nice try. I don't like the reflection in the eye, but good detail in the face (wrinkles), but focus seems a bit soft on the fingers.

Eyes Sq On
by redfig

Comment by smellyfish1002:
This shot is one of my favorites this week! Great idea. I would have liked to see more of the image that is cut off at the right side of the frame. I like that the eye is not in the center of the 'square, but I think it would have better balance if it were further from the upper right of the thumb. This is a good shot and I give it an 8. I would try some more versions and work with placement of the eye within the fingers. This is a fun idea that I would try to get the best image possible to enjoy, not just for the challenge!
JD Anderson 8

Eyes Sq On
by redfig

Comment by nds:
A very creative interpretation of the challenge and a well done shot too. Perhaps I would have cropped a little different. IMHO the photo shows too much of the hand in the upper left corner. Overall it could be a little sharper too. Nevertheless a beautiful shot, I voted 8. Good luck!

Eyes Sq On
by redfig

Comment by vestanpance:
Nice idea but I would have liked to have seen more of the hand on the right of frame.

Eyes Sq On
by redfig

Comment by tiff:
you photo is one of the best i have seen so far, its very creative and neat to look at. the light in you image looks really good as well, great job hope you win!

Eyes Sq On
by redfig

Comment by W.R.Miller:
Very nice shot. I really like it because of it's originality. Thanks for not posting a picture of a keyboard. :-)

Bill Miller (wackybill)

Eyes Sq On
by redfig

Comment by digitallywet:
love your pic, it was what i wanted to do but never got my arse into gear, like how you did it a lot though, much better than i may have done.