The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by strangeghost:
Or perhaps "bassist, but who knew? Nice effect with the BW and grain. I also like the tightness of the crop. Really good photo.

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by xtabintun:
The photo is a good composition, however it's too grainy for my tastes. Plus, he's a bassist! 6

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by DarkRider:
I'm sure that others have told you already the he is playing a bass not a guitar. Other then that I really like the hard light on his hand and the soft light on his face it draws some attention to his expression but the lighting on his hand really amplifies where his attention is at. And the noise adds a great mood to this pic.

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by Gil P:
very nice shot, I hope no ones complains about the grain...I think it creates a vibrant mood....but the title is wrong...he's playing bass!!!

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by DougPaz:
I'm not sure EVERYONE will like it but I really enjoy the grain in this shot. It might be cropped just a bit too tight at the top but I like it alot!

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by wkmen:
nice concert shot - the grain works well, highlights and shadows are interesting

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by saintaugust:
i dont know, i just dont think the grain here works.
maybe more contrast?

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by jimmyn4:
Looks like a picture that I would see in the liner notes for a CD. I don't like the technique used to make it look like regular film. It doesn't work for me because it is too uniform and looks like it was intentially applied (4).

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by Kavey:
I like the candid nature and the atmospheric lighting and grain. That said, would still prefer a touch more detail to his nearer eye. 7 (//www.dpchallenge.com/forum.php?action=read&FORUM_THREAD_ID=129433)

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by oskar:
Personally I dont like all that grain. But I know that it is intentional so that will not lower the score. But one thing I can say is not good enough is the lighting on his face. And you know I',m just being extra hard on you because this is masters :)