Aussie Drop Bear
by whatsthatbeeping

Comment by Claya:
Sorry, don't get it but I won't count that against you much since I think this challenge have a limited amount of universal appeal.

Aussie Drop Bear
by whatsthatbeeping

Comment by kloutit:
as an australian i have to vote this one well

Through the Neigbours Window
by whatsthatbeeping

Comment by electina:
Wonderful minimal abstract!

Through the Neigbours Window
by whatsthatbeeping

Comment by Cutter:
I can't tell what is in your neighbor's window...

Through the Neigbours Window
by whatsthatbeeping

Comment by Judi:
Good abstract image.

Through the Neigbours Window
by whatsthatbeeping

Comment by pacpinto:
The subject is no good. Sorry... nothing to see here, move along...

Through the Neigbours Window
by whatsthatbeeping

Comment by albc28:
It's hard to see what is actually being photographed. I can't tell if you are looking out a window or if you are getting a reflection of a rooftop. Are those blinds or is it light?

Through the Neigbours Window
by whatsthatbeeping

Comment by BrianR:
without title, the image is hard to follow...

Palm Tree
by whatsthatbeeping

Comment by Macadoo:
Really cool shot. I did not get the Palm tree until I saw the title but now I got it.

Just my opinion but I tried cropping the railing at the top and right even though there is a 45 degree remnant in the top right corner. Also cropped from bottom up to palm frond tip. For my personal taste that made the composition stronger.

Hope this is helpful.

Bruce

Palm Tree
by whatsthatbeeping

Comment by Phil:
Greetings from the Critique Club Tim!

Overall I like the image. The overexposure works well here and crop on the right side with the window barriers is dead on perfect (straight). Great looking piece of architecture indeed.

What got you here is the left side of the shot. The voters want symmetry for ceiling shots, detailing all of the wonderful archtecture. The part on the left is distracting enough for them not to give you many 8's which is needed for a high placement. Technicals are great but the composition just leaves me wanting a bit more.

Thanks for the opportunity to critique this image Tim!

Cheers - Phil