Moon cactus
by br1bar

Comment by Nuzzer:
Hi from the Critique Club.

Fit: Yep, it is a landscape

Composition: Why the angle? It just makes us want to tilt our head to look at the image. Normal boring flat horizons are best. Neither the moon nor the plants seem to be the main focus yet the title implies they should be. The lighting on the foreground pulls our eye there.

Technical: Interesting lighting. A bit bright though.

Feel: Like most voters I dont quite know what to make of this.

Good luck in future challenge.
PM me if you have any queries

Moon cactus
by br1bar

Comment by sprite777:
Did you just pick two random objects in the photo and put them together for a title? Could this have equally been called "rock bush"?

Moon cactus
by br1bar

Comment by Rankles:
Nice idea, but a little orange. Also a strange angle to shoot from, and an odd choice of composition.

Moon cactus
by br1bar

Comment by moosehead:
Nice evening shot.

Moon cactus
by br1bar

Comment by Grainey:
nice lighting

Moon cactus
by br1bar

Comment by nitro102:
The angle dosen't work. 3

Moon cactus
by br1bar

Comment by geoffb:
Interesting shot.