Reflections of Autumn
by SJCarter

Comment:
Very nice Jimmy. I love the juxtaposition of the leaves and their superimposition on the reflected branches. Excellent!

The Windmill
by Jutilda

Comment:
Add me to the list of "Wow - Nice photo" people. Excellent PP. Very nice Judy!

Projectile White
by Strikeslip

Comment:
*Comment not from the critique club*

I feel more focus on the bowl itself, or maybe the spew, may have added to the impact of this reguritory photograph. The action, while being dynamic, is secondary due to the focus is on the Slippy.

A title along the lines of "Milk: It just doesn't mix with vodka" or some such may have pushed this image into ribbon range.

While I do enjoy the spew that has missed th bowl, I feel that the photo itself would be helped if the missed spew were cloned (obviously not viable during for the challenge). Also there are some areas of spew that appear blown out, these though are not as distracting as the spew itself.

Note: I am viewing this image on my macloptop monitor so it may or may not be optimal. Hopefully Canadian spew isn't degraded when viewed on a McScreen.

Sonoma Vineyards
by rjkstesch

Comment:
What an excellent photograph. I love the fg, the mideground, and the bg. The leading lines are excellent. The hues are spectacular. The crop is very very nice - couldn't be better. The fog in the bg is somewhat difficult to ascertain from the photo itself - an alternate title like "Fog in the Distance" or some such would cure that.

Overall: excellent photo! Hoo doggy!

Ethereal
by Dax-

Comment:
Bea-utiful! Great photo, congrats on the top ten!

The Veil
by idnic

Comment:
Underrated.

lindsey 810.jpg
by jacler

Comment:
Light seems too harsh, it looks like she's squinting and uncomfortable. B/W might make this photo pop a little more, but the squint from the light takes away from the overall feel.

wondering
by jacler

Comment:
I like the softness of this one. On first glance the tonal range doesn't seem full, but I don't think it needs to be there. I like the pose, the expression. Iffy on the arm in then out then in on the left side, but I don't find it a distraction. Second thought - it works for me. Nice photo.

Wandering II
by Dax-

Comment:
You're probably getting tired of me saying "Wow! I love this photo" but I'm going to say it anyway. Your mastery of color, shading, and texture is amazing. Just once I'm going to find something in one of your artworks that I can say "blahblahblah just doesn't do it for me" - I have serious doubts that I'll ever get to say that.

Edit for sp.

Message edited by author 2005-11-28 13:01:50.

keeping the guests busy.jpg
by Shecoya

Comment:
I *have* to start flying Canadian - the best fun I've had on a plane here is trying to open one of those little bags of pretzels without clocking the person next to me.

Nice to see our neighbors to the north excel in Aerial Customer Service.

(Hopefully you were sporting your teeth during the flight :)