Swinging by the Park
by Cutter

Comment:
This is really about the moment. Great photo.....I expected blue jeans here not french cuffs! Also, I love, LOVE, how my eye travels through this photo....DOF and contrast working perfectly! I would like to have just a bit more of the overhanging branch (to meld with the frame.)

Comfort Trifecta: Morning sun, quilt, cat
by Melethia

Comment:
I love cats! Got two in my lap right now...I typically hate cat photo's...they are too easy......but, you have captured a wonderful expression here. Comforting! Nice.

Bath Time
by jaylen

Comment:
w

Knitting & Tea - Sweet Solace for Me
by Sammie

Comment:
love the mottled light but the composition just isn't that interesting to me.

A long lasting pair
by tanubiswas

Comment:
I know what you're going for but, it doesnt work......don't think crop ... think re-shoot. Also, remember that everything in your frame you are responsible for and I think that bit of trash beside your right foot just happened to be there.

Pink and Furry
by Jutilda

Comment:
I told my girlfriend that this weeks challenge was "comfort." She raised her leg and showed me her "house shoes." So, this must be good,
The positive: nice framing and good light (would have like a lbit of a reflector to get the sole of the right slipper.
The negative: wash those things! :)

The love of a child
by kashi

Comment:
Someone loves the photographer! That is obvious!
The negative: horribly distracting background and give me that right heel.
The positive: great catchlight in the eyes, wonderful moment, and I actually like the overall framing of the shot if you'd drop it just a smidge (Note: the first time in my life I've used the word smidge! :) )

go on or give up
by gazdi

Comment:
I'm going through my votes in reverse order and commenting on as many as I can .... this shot to me has a lot of potential and I actually think the grain......buh...'scuse me.....NOISE.....adds to the shot. That being said, it's lacking something to live up to the title.
Why am I going on? To me, artistically speaking, don't see going on here. Why would I leave the light to drop off the end into the dark?
I will say that you have me thinking....and, maybe that is the most important thing.....
I gave the photo a 3.

Oystermen on Apalch Bay
by zmanii

Comment:
Fabulous photograph! The toning is perfect! I think 9 out of 10 photographers put in you same locale would have overlooked this shot! Unfortunately, I think I'm one of the 9.

Green Bug Blue Background
by hare

Comment:
not a duotone but a nice shot!