Clearaudio Turntable with BENZ L2 MM Catridge - Analog Music Rocks !!!!
by andrewt

Comment:
A good quality stock/ product shot. Very well controlled lighting, exposure and DOF. In those areas, it'll be a 10/10

Since this is a product shot, I would improve on 2 areas (rather minor)
1) The framing - I'll give it a little more room on both the left and right. This will improve the "usability" of the photo in magazines and catalogs. Moreover, the crop of the photo gives it a rather tight feel.
2) The table line at the bottom is not "contributing". Meaning it's not adding value to the shot. The reason you've put the product against a plain background is to bring out the product and make it stand out. The table line (edge) is rather distracting. I would crop it out.

An overall 8 for me. A lot of technical consideration had gone into this shot!

Banana Flavoured Milk
by Pug-H

Comment:
Watch the shadows. For a product shoot, it'll make or break the photo. In This case, the shadow is too "artificial". Usually, for a stock photo, it'll be good to not have shadow. But for product shots, it might be better to have some natural shadows. Other than that, the framing, composition is good. Hope this helps.

Absolut Sparkle
by VitaminB

Comment:
Interesting effect! - Good execution. Nice lighting control too. 10 for me

Antique doll
by BarbB

Comment:
Beautiful. Perfect composition and lighting. I like! - 10 for me

I want to be a...
by Simms

Comment:
Nice composition. The colors might be a little over-exposed. But still, good overall. 7 for me

Arturo Fuente Cigars
by timfythetoo

Comment:
Nice mood! I like the presentation. 9 for me

Come Fly With Us
by RayEthier

Comment:
Excellent colors and contrast! I like!
8 for me

Ducks of a Feather, Flock Together
by GueDesigns

Comment:
Beautiful. Nice framing and sharpness - 9 for me

"2" Drops on a Leaf
by Lydia

Comment:
Nice concept and idea. Good execution. 10 for me!

Glass Double
by IreneM

Comment:
Nice lighting control and composition. a 10 for me!