I gave this a 5. I thought the concept was 'ok' but .. the 'blue', sad, etc.. is not my taste/style, so I am likely not the best to provide feedback. Having said that, this Challenge of course opened up the perfect opportunity for such shots and therefore was 'acceptable', if that makes sense, and I think you captured that 'sense' fairly well. Quality wise it looks like it could be sharper, but it might be resizing issues, not sure. Perhaps a variation in perspective/angle, a different reflective surface used, more attention paid to 'composition'/subject placement and a more finely tuned crop, may have made this better in my opinion. Perhaps also 'using' the glass transparency more into your shot may have added another element as well. Sure isn't "rotten" in my opinion. |