|This is Kari Ann, greetings from the Critique Club:
composition: interesting composition, i like how you can see the trunk, but the rest of the iamge has to be viewed by reflection
color: black adn white conversion is very nice, good tones
contrast: again, the tones are very well controlled, and the full spectrum is there to make it visually appealing
focus: good focus, and even the reflection is still pretty well discernible
depth of field:pretty safe aperture, but works well
lighting: nice evening lighting im assuming. makes the tones in the water really stand out against the dark banks of the water
other: a pretty picture, but not much else going for it. the composition could have been helped by getting rid of the bank in the lower left corner, but this may have been the safest composition you could be accessed to. only downfall is the overall 'wow' of the image, it lacks 'wow'. I really hope this critique was helpful to you. If you ever have any other questions regarding, please feel free to PM me whenever.