Grapes of Wrath
by snaffles

Comment:
Quite timeless in its angriness
7

Damn Dust - The Grapes of Wrath
by Rmac

Comment:
Well caught the menacing broken window almost casting a threatening shadow. And the damn dust
Nice composition
7

Lord of the Flies
by jaysonmc

Comment:
A cute picture of two lovely boys playing in a rather peaceful forest, shoehorned for the challenge
5

'Something Wicked This Way Comes' by Ray Bradbury
by IAmEliKatz

Comment:
Nice, but in a deja vu way. In any case it does not have enough fantasy and horror to match the novel
5

"Please Sir, I want some more"
by Shifty_Powers

Comment:
Dickens-iana , only that the bowl had to be made of metal and the hands of a young boy and not so delicate and clean!
Nevertheless, a nice image - a square crop might be even better
7

Wuthering Heights
by wdamman

Comment:
So much sharpening that the image trembles.
I know that it does not matter for a photo inspired by a classic novel, but showing a house implies some kind of faithfulness to the book. And I remember vaguely as having elaborate gothic designs around the front door.
I do not want a literal image, but I think that you aimed for one.
I wish I can mark this with a 5 but the processing is way too disturbing
4

The Secret Garden
by lunachicken

Comment:
Beautiful, well felt shot, I particularly like the B&W treatment. I am glad that I looked at this shot on a different monitor because the darkness obscures almost totally the little boy.
It lacks though this element that I was looking for here: the magic.
7

On Golden Pond
by dtremain

Comment:
This place must be mesmerizing in reality but as a photo it is boring and not too craftily taken. The sky makes everything pale and common
4

The Secret Garden
by giantmike

Comment:
Why is the secret garden so violently colored to the point of losing its magic? Why such sharpening?
The composition would be twice as interesting without being attacked by a poisonous red
5

The Phantom of the Opera (1920. Gaston Leroux)
by Denielle

Comment:
a little simplistic, a little indecisive, a little boring
5