yep...we have no bananas
by JenHall

Comment by nicoledb:
* From the Critique Club *

The composition could have been interesting, but the tops of the bananas all lead my eye out of the picture instead of into it. Texture of the banana skins looks interesting, though the picture is too small to judge well. The B&W works well with the overripened skins.

Could have been a reasonably good picture, but the size really hurt it. Congrats on the brown ribbon, although I'm not sure you really deserved that.

Message edited by author 2004-06-04 14:38:41.

yep...we have no bananas
by JenHall

Comment by cl3ft:
I really liked it, it is simple and has a lot more character than most of the banana shots, face it bright yellow bananas have been done and done and done, This looks like bananas at my place :)
But I agree it could have been bigger though.

Cheers

cl3ft

yep...we have no bananas
by JenHall

Comment by suemack:
like the focus, dof, concept of this photo but the image is very small on the monitor

yep...we have no bananas
by JenHall

Comment by Tallbloke:
Strange idea desaturating this image I, I think it would work better seeing the yellows and brown splodges.

yep...we have no bananas
by JenHall

Comment by KaDi:
But you do have the beginnings of a great banana bread . . . 1 point for bananas, 1 point for image tone, 1 point for cropping and composition, 1 point for being brave, and 1 more for your sense of humor. (Hope a 5's o.k. with you.)

yep...we have no bananas
by JenHall

Comment by DefyTime:
that's disgusting, very different, better if it were bigger, good though

GrandmasHands.jpg
by JenHall

Comment by Neil:
Excellent shot. Congrats on POTD.

harsh
by JenHall

Comment by Flash:
6. I'm intrigued. Not moved with a mood, but intrigued.

harsh
by JenHall

Comment by mzanoni:
Good shapes and lines. Texture on frame is a good touch.

harsh
by JenHall

Comment by LucidLotus:
An interesting image. The lighting is good - I can see a connection between its harshness and the broken glass, but I'm not sure the two together give me that 'harsh' feeling. The focus looks great, the darker colors help the feeling of the piece. I'm not sure I like the composition though - I keep wanting to see something along the bottom to help frame up the image of the glass. Not sure why. Nicely done. 6