A Most Unusual Pet
by debitipton

Comment:
Why yes it is! But a lovely one all the same!

Nice shot, good colors but the light to dark doesn't quite work for me for some reason. I'm thinking maybe because it's not more balanced, the light extends to far to the right and the overall crop seems a bit lop sided with the extra space on the left. Also the ear getting cut off doesn't quite work for me on a personal level when the rest of the shot has so much space around it. Maybe if you cropped in closer around the face, let me grab my majic envelopes here, hang on.............................Oh yeah, crop right in close to the face and under the chin and the ear works much better and gives the viewer a real feel for this one. A 7

Cesar goes for the prey
by palmfrodur

Comment:
Man, don't mess with Cesar! Look at the intensity in those eyes! Very nice capture, very candid and composition works to a point. Cesar is looing off toward the front right just a bit, the negative space on the left leaves the shot looking slightly off balanced, if it could have been cropped so the other side had the extra space............

A 7

Stud
by parrothead

Comment:
Wow, what a stud he is too! The one in Gale's barn is named AJ, short for AppleJack.

This is a very nice shot, the angle is well done but I could have lived without the butt, LOL! :)

Coloration decsion was well done, just a bit of a bright spot on his nose but nothing major. Was at an 8 (because of the butt) but I'll forgive you for that and raise you to a 9 :)

Philip-Head & Neck Portrait
by lynnesite

Comment:
WOW! I love it when they RUN! And you get the mane standing up like that! And the colors, the vibrant colors and the expression are priceless! So well done and then you had to go ruin the shot (for me personally) with the blurry edge. It would have been okay in the front and behind the mane and above the back but it's extended into the back and across the bottom and while you might have been trying to create a vinette or sorts it just didn't work for me personally. Is there any chance I could see the original on this one sometime? Hope I didn't offend. An 8

Madeline's Pony
by gwendy

Comment:
Have to comment on the horse picture! Lovely pony there, I love their shaggy manes!

A very nice shot overall and the conversion to black and white works well here. Just a few things bother me about the overall shot. The little girl doesn't look very happy for some reason, expressions are big to me in shots like this. Even is she wasn't smiling, her eyes still tell me she's bored and wants this to be over with. Maybe a shot with just the horse might do better, she ends up taking away from the friendly feel with her expression and I'm sorry if this hurts your feelings, I know what it's like to have kids who won't co-operate sometimes. As for the horse, very nice, bit of hay in his forlock there and he'snot really interested either. Just staring off, waiting for something, anything, I'm not sure what. I love shooting horses but one of the biggest pains is getting and keeping their attention for any length of time, even seconds! They can be as finicky as cats sometimes! a 7

Fido, the toothless watchdog
by lwkimages

Comment:
Okay, I had to comment on the Chicken. My father raised these when I was growing up and we had one that was the meanest, nastiest rooster you would ever want to meet. You could kick that bugger clear across the yard and he'd come running back to fight again. He would even spur the car tires AS THE CAR WAS MOVING! He was nuts! It was shame he got killed when he tried to run ripshod over the geese and they chased him into their bathtub and piled in on top of him and drowned him, not that me and my sister sat there and watched them do it (we really hated that rooster but my dad wouldn't kill him).

Anyway, now that you have my story, here is my take on your little feathered friend here. First pass you got a 7 because I really didn't expect to see a chicken in here and the background threw me for some reason. Second pass, taking a little more time to look at it, the clarity, the lighting, the overall composition is there but something is still lacking, maybe it's the color, I see the reds but don't really feel them. And the darkness on the left side of the background bothers me just a bit, not sure why. But the long of the short of all this, since you read my whole story and did such a wonderful job capturing this feathered friend, I'm raising your score 2 points to a 9! :)

That Face
by massulo

Comment:
Is asking you, "JUST WHAT DO YOU THINK YOU ARE DOING?" Very cute!

A nice shot, the angle is well done but the fuzzy fur on the left lower corner is a bit distracting and the broad line that goes up between the ears is also a bit distracting. Using my magic envelopes, if you crop a bit off the left, right and bottom, really bringing the face to the center and even cutting the ears off just a bit it makes a big difference i how I see the cat. A 7

Digger
by bobdaveant

Comment:
Awww, so cute! Digger is adorable and so sweet looking!

I love the light capture on the eye, showing just a bit of blue, a reflection or does Digger have blue eyes? The lighting is a bit yellowish, and the door in the background is just a bit distracting. A 7

Bayoo
by JiaBob

Comment:
Cute! Nice capture, not easy shooting a fish, unless they are in a barrel of course! Just kidding.

An Oscar? Interesting to look at but the lighting leaves much to be desired, very dull and flat and all the debris or algea in the shot could either be cropped out or cloned out. Some adjustments in Levels or Curves to help the colors really pop and you would have a fantastic shot here instead of just a great one! :) A 7

My Smiling "Kid"
by JScho

Comment:
How cute! We had a pet goat growing up as well. They are quite the characters!

This is a lovely shot, the little smile on his face but with the angle of the shot it almost looks like one of those cards where the dog/cat's head is way too big for the body. Same effect here, the body doesn't look like it could really belong to this same animal. I like the lighting but the colors still came out just a tad dull. A 7