5.6183
by SEG

Comment:
I don't find this engaging enough to warrant a 5.6, personally.
I figure you for a 5.38

5.3232
by tome

Comment:
I like the ominous-ness of this cloud cover.
score prediction is likely close as well.
5.1875

6.3
by patches

Comment:
nice lighting here, you're probably close with your guess.
6.2850

9
by Len Scap

Comment:
a little over-reaching, but that's not a bad thing.
I figure a 6.33 for this

5.1266
by 2mccs

Comment:
interesting slice-of-life.
I figure a 4.85

Sum of These
by GeneralE

Comment:
and some of those?

not an overly engaging image, hopefully your score is higher than the sum.
I figure you'll end up around a 4.16

4.2317
by mitalapo

Comment:
I'm trying to figure out what you're using for the reflection and I can't come up with it...interesting to see if it's in notes

I like the extreme light/darks in this.

I guess this will end around a 4.3887

5,8
by Mona

Comment:
interesting crystallization on the snow, but I don't find it overly engaging otherwise.
5.1330

Majesty
by Cory

Comment:
have to say, not to offend, but I couldn't help but think of the mocking comments regarding Peter Lik and how he "waited his whole life to find that perfect setup, with the moon rising behind the tree..."

it seemed like an obvious shot from the Lik challenge, and well done, but that's all I could think of when I was voting on this.
still netted a 7 from me...just thought I'd stop back in and see whose image it was :)

A Beautiful Ending
by njsabs

Comment:
took a screengrab, played with flipping every possible way...the only way this looked even remotely close to as good (in my opinion) was a tighter crop below (starting just below the first reflection of the face, putting the head in the lower left 1/4 of the image).
I gave this an 8 and feel confident that it deserved it. I really think that just about anything else you did would've detracted overall from the score you received.