Life Is Just A Tire Swing
by ErinKirsten

Comment:
Ahhh, a tire swing - one of a trees great gifts to children.
Because of the white sky, I'd be tempted to see what this looked like in black and white with maybe a slight contrast boost. And though this might seem odd for a challenge in which the tree is supposed to star, I would also look at cropping some off the right. I do enjoy this, though, and it's a 7 from me.

Tree on the hill
by P-A-U-L

Comment:
Great light and you handled that sun so well. I like that you included the entire expanse of this lone tree. Voted earlier.

Winter Giant
by JustinM

Comment:
One of my favorites - light is gorgeous and it's all about that giant tree. It might be a little too blue, but that's a tricky call and the tones are very appealing.

Outsiders
by Bear_Music

Comment:
Nice perspective - beautiful scene and great color. I like the balance of the composition, too. Voted earlier.

Up in Smoke
by BaldurT

Comment:
Super lighting and tones. Interesting subject, situation, clothing. Very well done. 9 from me. Voted several days ago.

no exit
by tate

Comment:
I cannot figure out how you did this in Standard but I'm assuming two models. It's intriguing and suggests a story. The indoor/outdoor lighting are very well handled. 9 from me. Voted several days ago.

We don't see the world as it is, we see it as we are.
by roz

Comment:
Blue in my book. 10. Engaging natural expressions and poses. Interesting situation. Emotional and artistic appeal. Incredible editing. This one has it all.
I voted several days ago.

Ad Astra Per Aspera
by mariuca

Comment:
Great light and tones.

The ancient one
by Neat

Comment:
My goodness but that's a huge tree!!! And the perspective . . . with the tiny little bench . . . just emphasizes that. Tones are great, too.

plant a few
by Lydia

Comment:
This one really appeals to me for its simplicity and impact. I find it visually appealing and right on for the challenge.