Santa Fe
by franktheyank

Comment:
Love this gate. I think the photo could be dark in places, more contrast. I also think the photo would benefit from cropping everything below the step. Still I like it.

Knockin’ on Heaven’s Door
by Kevin_Flynn

Comment:
With the lamp right in front of the door its important to choose the right angle to take this photograph, I'm not convinced the artist did, but I'm not convinced he/she didn't. What I'm trying to say is that the placement of the lamp is a little awkward, whilst the angle of the door is good and it doesn't look like there would actually be a better place to take the photo from. I feel the same about the shadow of the lamp. The lighting in the photo is great, only that time of day would produce that lighting, but for me the shadow of the lamp is in the wrong place.
In the end: colours, details, crispness and editing all good. Composition: unsure.

Do Not Disturb
by Art Roflmao

Comment:
Nice wood, Nice handles. No hole for the lock is a feature that appeals to me. I find the rest hideous. Having said that, the levels and contrast and saturation and such like are good.

the door between
by BrennanOB

Comment:
I really quite like this photo. It's not overly complicated, captures all the details of the paint and lack paint, has pleasant lighting and nicely place shadows. Bravo.

waiting for the key
by posthumous

Comment:
Bit too abstract. Not that interesting.

Green-Meldrim House ~ 1833
by Ja-9

Comment:
If I put my hand over the bottom half of this photo I'd probably have scored it higher. The top half has a moody feel, a noisy grain lots of different forms of details. But if you include the bottom half I think the image is over-crowded and a little confused.

Welcome Home Dad
by rehans

Comment:
Beautiful dog, but I'm not sure if the photo displays the details of the subject (the door) particularly well. The photo itself doesn't do it for me.

Post Office Boxes
by kleski

Comment:
The patterns and symmetry are pleasing.

BRINKS
by tfarrell23

Comment:
Whilst the subject isn't very interesting, the photo makes it interesting (seems to be what the challenge is asking for). Obviously a photo taken by somebody that knows how light works and how to use their camera. The depth of field is very pleasing. The texture of the locks metal is beautifully captured and then contrasted by the smooth and shiney keys. The yellowy gold of the lock works really well with the orangey red of the floor. Great contrast and levels too.

Neglected Beauty
by Tommy_Mac

Comment:
Another image with some lovely details. Unfortunately I find the photo flat and lifeless. I touch of editing could have brought the image to life, more contrast maybe, definitely needs some saturation.