Hey! That's My Hay
by BAMartin

Comment:
lovely shot. Great lighting, wonderfull building, very nice horse. nice clean crisp image that tells a story. The only flaw i see in the shot is that your "horizon line is off you need to rotate the image a couple degees ccw. other wise perfect 9

Gate
by typologic

Comment:
while technicaly a decent photo I feel that this is just not a very exciting shot. It apears to be another shot of another dog taken from the same focus on the nose angle. (not intending to sound rude). I don't mind pet shots I would just like to see them done from different angles. I will acnowledge however that the shot fits the challenge and is technicaly a good shot.

And the Facade Will Fall Away
by Mr_Pants

Comment:
fits the challenge well. Lighting was not bad the focus is good. Stong lines. but the topic is about as interesting as watching astro turf grow,,, sorry not intending to sound meen But it is so beautifly shot yet so uninteresting..

Bound in Love, Separated by Law
by Jesuispeure

Comment:
wow great shot and strong message. The B&W was a perfect choice. Great lighting, strong message, wonderfull line wonderfully done. My first 10 of the challenge!!

Angles
by Sonda

Comment:
umm ok it's a white painted curb.. I fail to see the separation. I see the nice lines and curves. But I fail to see the interest of the separation .

Window Shades
by Imagineer

Comment:
Holey fibberty jibbits. I love this shot. The lines, light and color are spectacular. But I dont see the shades... where is the separation you were trying to show me? This would have been a 9 or 10 in an abstract or achetecture challenge. But alas I see not the separation.. So I will have to frown and give this lovely shot a 7

Only one can win...
by nateconnella

Comment:
nope I don't like the lighting one bit. Fits the challenge, great angle, decent focus but I can't stand the lighting. the yellow orange hue through every thing looks sickly and the bright spot on the wall looks realy bad. With good lighting this could easily have recieved an 8 from me as is its a little below average.

The bookmark
by RUEDISCHMUTZ

Comment:
very creative toke on separation. I feel hower that a little less angle on the pook showong lee of the writting would be nice. I also think this could have benifited from some back lighting. An average shot. but with a very creative Idea 6

Final Separation
by graphicfunk

Comment:
Decent shot but a little too dark IMO. I feel it fits the challenge well. I do feel however that this looks staged a more candid feel would ahve done better for me. I also would like to have seen so soldier in the picture a little closser. .. a Dear Mrs. Doe .. your son private .... would have realy brought some tears to the eyeys. Nice job.

This Land is My Land
by nards656

Comment:
I love the shot but I fail to see the separation. I think you are trying in insinuate the separation of the hair from the horse or cow. In order for me to feel this separation I would need to see the animal in the photo. As it is is is hair. With the animal it is hair and animal separated. great shot dosn't fit the challenge well IMO. so I can't justify more than a very healthy 6. With the animal in the shot 8 or 9..