Rusty Extraction
by Michaels

Comment:
Really great photo. Even the almost white background works. If you are going to do more backlit photos like this, it might be worth looking for a more interesting translucent background.

A9.

Decomposing
by johnm

Comment:
when what I like about a photo is the reflection of a flash on a window, I am afraid I have completely missed your intent.

A 3.

railway exchange
by walbland

Comment:
Very good except for litter in background. There are many ways including picking up the litter, that could have been used to remove it from this composition.

A 6.

Through and Through
by LENWOODBLUZ

Comment:
Very, very, nice, and I don't have a clue what it is that I am looking at.

A 10.

Scale
by boxjockeys

Comment:
This looks like it could be quite an interesting subject. The lighting and contrast combine to make this image very muted.

A 2.

Farm Grain Conveyor (Screwtype)
by skief

Comment:
This photo provides an adequate documentation of its subject matter, but lacks aesthetic qualities such of choice of what to include and exclude.

A 2.

Locked
by OneSweetSin

Comment:
Very nice image well photographed. Good composition and use of aperture. I like the three very different metal surfaces very much balanced in size and position.

A slight counter clockwise rotation, might have provided a simpler cropping for the top edge.

An 8.

Rusty...The Dog
by Kneeforu

Comment:
I really like this. It is a very cute image, nice colors, nice composition, ant one of really attractive photos of rust.
A 10 and I hope you do really well with this.

Captivity
by maciupiciu

Comment:
I liked the autumn feel this has especially when it is spring where I live. It also has a late afternoon mood. The bends and twists of the heavy iron bars are also very appealing, well lit, and adequately focused to make the photo interesting and appealing.
I would have liked more focus on the very nearest bar and tighter cropping at the top.
A 6.

Past Their Prime (Unedited)
by trnqlty

Comment:
I like the framing of the opening and the variety and positioning of the rusting wheels. Nice focus and depth of field.

I would have preferred a point of view to the right and above that of the current camera position. There is something in the background here that is distracting. I also would have liked less negative space and tighter cropping almost to the edge of the window.
A 5.