Luxury Shirt
by h2

Comment:
Great job, I had to try this out for myself. Steps were easy to follow and photographed very well. You should try making the dollar bill crab if you haven't already. I used to leave that one for tips in high school. It's a challenge but pretty neat once you get it done.

I'm New
by Kelli

Comment:
This has potential to be a good image, but the black dots in the shadow areas really ruin it for me. Was the lighting really dim for this? To me it looks like maybe the shadows were brightened up too much in post leaving them really grainy, but I've never seen noise that looked quite like that. Maybe the conversion to B&W amplified it as well. If you didn't see what I'm talking about when editing your image, make sure your monitor is calibrated so you can see all the shades of white and black when you preview your image

seamline
by mitalapo

Comment:
Beautiful shot. I really like how you did the ripped and taped look to separate the scenes.

On my screen I can see a little square surrounding the moon that's just slightly different than the rest of the sky. I'm assuming the moon was shot separately from the night picture and what I'm seeing is the square crop that was used to copy the moon into the scene? There's also a little section about 3-4 moon widths wide and 1 high, directly above and running to the left of the moon that has the same contrast difference. Looks to me like a cloud was brushed out with a hard brush. If so using a softer brush with some feathering would have blended it into the background sky better.

Gave you a 9, as I really like this. Think this would look wonderful on a big piece of canvas in someones living room.

froggat edge
by Giles

Comment:
Just came across this. Kinda surprised it scored so low, nice image and I really like the colors. Looks like you got some sensor dust in your sky that you could of cloned out, but overall the image is pretty good.

Rules
by gyaban

Comment:
This has to ribbon, wonderful job. Love the no elephant balloons sign. Only thing I can think to improve, is the top border looks off to me, being smaller than the sides. But that's a very minor gripe on an excellent job taking advantage of the expert ruleset.

Into The Abyss
by scarbrd

Comment:
Thanks for posting the unedited version. I really like seeing the before/after shots. Excellent job with the editing. So much more detail that you managed to pull out of the original pic. Good job.

View from the front porch - 2
by Kelli

Comment:
I'm so jealous. The storm we got ended up being nothing more than an afternoon of ice and 16 degree temps. I want snow!

The Little Cabin by the Lake
by ronaldfw

Comment:
Great shot, this should of scored much higher. Definitely one of my faves for the challenge.

Construction Zone
by dswann

Comment:
Congrats on your ribbon. I voted you a bit below the curve. I gave you a 5 and thought I'd let you know why. You did a really good job getting the miniature feel to your photo but one thing bothered me and that is the mud. To me it's just too bright and wet looking and so it stands out. I'm curious what this would look like with the browns desat or somehow processed so that it looks like dirt instead of mud.

Sophie
by Paul

Comment:
I liked this, gave you a 7. Seems it was voted as a miniature challenge though.