Ripeness Descending
by jessfrolio

Comment:
I wish the crop wasn't so tight at the bottom but this a great capture which fits the theme very well indeed.

Technology
by carlos

Comment:
I find the 'speckles' on the surface very distracting.

Great Grandaughter
by SteveJ

Comment:
The person in the background is distracting and the blown out area a little overpowering.

Baby is not in sharp focus and you can't see her eyes. Babies have the most amazing eyes and I find that if you don't capture them you lose the emotion. In this case maybe that's not so important as it is a more candid type shot and not a portrait but I still find myself wishing I could see her eyes a bit better.

The Coin Collector
by Stagolee

Comment:
One of the best coin pictures from this challenge.

You've done a great job with the lighting there and I like the reflections. Tough to get right with only basic editing but you pulled it off. 7

Power - Wind and Wires
by Melethia

Comment:
I am the most pedantic man on the planet so I can't ignore the fact that the windmill is not for generating power but for drawing water. This sort of spoils the idea behind the picture for me.

The picture itself is well done, I like the composition and the crop.

World of Bright Colors
by Montereykiddo

Comment:
Title says bright colours but they are not bright on my monitor, looks very dark.

If the old vs. new is the crayons then I think it is a weak link to the challenge theme.

So simple......Yet so Sofisticated.
by hdogg4u

Comment:
Maybe I am being pedantic but that spelling mistake in the title really annoys me.

The idea and the image don't annoy me at all though, I like both. Imaginative take on the challenge theme.

Downsizing
by jamijc

Comment:
Although the idea is a bit 'obvious' and very similar to many other entries, this one really stands out from the crowd.

The composition really grabs me and the placement of the sleek, shiny iPod against the busy clutter of the CDs draws my eye nicely.

Old walkway to a new pier
by carotop111

Comment:
Really beautifully done this one. For me, one of the few to really stand out in this challenge and deserve a score higher than a 7.

Great job, it gets my 9.

Old is New and New is Old
by outland

Comment:
Not sure I'm a big fan of photos of photos. The background does nothing for me either.