Tack Sharp
by Montereykiddo

Comment:
Very nice, the worst thing I can think of to say is the shadow is off a tad. Pretty bad, huh? (LOL) You get a silver star.

Study in wood and tacks
by bpickard

Comment:
This is very good, straight forward. Highlights on the tacks, Maybe a little on the deep sepia side which I think hides details, but I wasn't there, so I don't know but you get top marks from me

Old Saw Mill
by drgsoell

Comment:
The color tones make it appear to be a very arid environment (well done if that was your intent) good image.... BUT (of course) the frame would be better if it was less dominent, prhaps the same tone as in the image.

Alone on the Hill
by riley

Comment:
I really like this image, the desaturation of the blues & greens forces the focus on the house, which is not overdone

The Horse Was Ridden Off Into The Sunset Long Ago
by Galimages

Comment:
You may as well cropped the light flare off the side of this image since it adds nothing to it and detracts from the overall. One of the better sepia type treatments I have seen in this challenge.

Delapidated
by Prime_Time

Comment:
The deep sepia obsures the details that are available in this image. By lightening the tone, the detail will emerge and the veiwer doesn't need to work to capture the feel, mood, emotion that should come easily. Heavy sharping, as has been done here, can not replace natural details that are not there or are lost. (By the way, IMO)

Abandoned Faith
by ladyhawk22

Comment:
The deep sepia obsures the details that are available in this image. By lightening the tone, the detail will emerge and the veiwer doesn't need to work to capture the feel, mood, emotion that should come easily. (By the way, IMO)

Welcome Home
by kirbic

Comment:
One of the more acceptable sepia treatments I have seen in this challenge and I am bumping you up two points for that and the composition since reveiwing my scoring.

"The Wars Of the Old Discard There Ruins For The New To Find "
by Jecto

Comment:
The deep sepia obsures the details that are available in this image. By lightening the tone, the detail will emerge and the veiwer doesn't need to work to capture the feel, mood, emotion that should come easily. The contrast between the grey tones in the sky and the sepia in the forground difficult to visually accept (By the way, IMO)

OLD SHED
by pookey83

Comment:
The deep sepia obsures the details that are available in this image. By lightening the tone, the detail will emerge and the veiwer doesn't need to work to capture the feel, mood, emotion that should come easily. (By the way, IMO)