Forgotten
by gisli

Comment:
7 - Forgotten and 'obsolete'. Great scene. Criticism; more definition, or contrast, not sure. Technically, while no 'expert' in the rule(s), seems you have placed the "point of interest" (as a whole) fairly strictly, however, for me, my 'eye' goes first to the 'head of the dragon' so, if that were nudged a little more to the left, with some more space on the right, may have made this an even better shot in my opinion. Not sure on the frame.

Shy Blushing Caterpillar
by Beagleboy

Comment:
7 - I like this but, criticism; which it were not so high key, more contrast left on the critter. The frame is too thick in my opinion and detracts, especially from the 'fragility' of the critter. Technically, while no 'expert', looks spot on to me. Just wish the vivid color shone through more boldly, and more detail too on the 'hairs'.

Sour milk
by trishialw

Comment:
5 - Good potential, nice colors, just the focus on the fore bubbles rather than the drop would have made this much better, and different crop, etc, in my opinion.

Beak Deep In Bubbles
by GolferDDS

Comment:
8 - Wow, great shot. For the Challenge though, well the focus is on the bubbles/foam, but the eagle(?) adds so much here. You have done very well. Great colors.

Island
by Discraft

Comment:
7 - Different, good abstract, nice colors. Like to see a little more detail in at least a couple of the bubbles though, but I realize you might lose the abstract.

Digital Bubbles
by huitzilopotchtli

Comment:
7 - Good, different, just seems a bit noisy, dark, shadowy, not sure. Perhaps a different angle, like to see more definition in the bubble(s).

Bubble reflections
by djfamine

Comment:
7 - Nice, just wish the bubble were bigger/more central/not cropped.

Bubbling Sunlight
by indy79

Comment:
7 - Good perspective. In my opinion this would be an even better shot without the sun, the lighting is nice 'around it', but it detracts too much, especially from the clarity of the bubbles.

Moon at the point of interest
by anireno

Comment:
7 - Very nice. Criticism; not much, given the Challenge. Technically, while no 'expert', seems you have applied the rule(s) strictly, so well done. Being a moon shot, and a nice one, I would like to see more detail, difficult with this Challenge, unless somehow the 'point of interest' were one of the craters or such, who knows. Not sure on the frame, possibly with a 'silver' color instead, not sure.

Nuts
by Imagineer

Comment:
8 - Like this and the colors and the 'face'. Criticism; if the nose were as sharp as the ears, especially for the Challenge (though while no 'expert' in the rule(s), you seem to have used them fairly strictly), would make this a better shot in my opinion. The 'out of focus mass' at the fore/bottom does not detract from this shot in my opinion, actually enhances it and the depth, in an odd way. Just like to see the face 'pop out' just a fraction more. Good perspective and angle, well done. Ok, up to 8 from 7, mainly for character.