The night walk
by GeorgesBogaert

Comment:
There are a lot of things in silhouette but what I believe to be the subject (the two girls) have a bit to much detail to be a true silhouette. Also, the overall photo is dark and very busy with my eye jumping to all the bright spots within it.

Just a Rim of Myself
by grahamgator

Comment:
I really like the photograph but for me a silhouette is against a light background. I will say it is one of the more interesting ones in the challenge but for me it is just not a silhouette. Great photograph but for me DMNC.

Wintry
by Luciemac

Comment:
Interesting and mesmerizing, great capture.

the lighthouse
by Abra

Comment:
Nice silhouette but would really have preferred a brighter background to make it stand out even more, it gets lost at the top where the sky is really dark and my eye wants to stay focused on the bright area in the middle.

racing for the cure
by tanguera

Comment:
Wonderful and perfect capture of a silhouette. To bad you did not blow out the object at the top so it was just solid white like they were running into the light. I do find that fence a bit distracting from the overall photograph.

Full Moon & Oklahoma State Capitol Building
by MadMan2k

Comment:
I am guessing that your silhouette is the little statue or what ever it is at the top of the building against the moon. I only noticed it because I was looking for the silhouette because that is what the challenge is. I really should not have to search that hard to see if the photograph even meets the challenge and for me the silhouette should be the subject of the photograph, not some tiny insignificant part.

I was wandering.
by RKT

Comment:
Interesting in a very abstract way, like how the silhouettes have shadows/silhouettes of their own.

HMQS Gayundah
by Beetle

Comment:
To me this is more just a dark photograph. A silhouette should be a shape or outline against a brighter background. Your background is marginally brighter in most of the areas, with only the small area to the right being significantly brighter.....this really makes the overall photograph to dark for my taste.

Treeline at dusk
by cdr1401

Comment:
Really great capture and good example of what a silhouette should be. Love the color of the sky and the fine intricate shapes that the tree branches form.

Huh?
by Judi

Comment:
You can not argue, this is most defiantly a silhouette. The background is just to over the top for me and I forget about the guy with the flag and my eye zeros in on that bright white spot. Would have been a much better photograph if the person was a bit larger in the frame and not what to me is more of a small after thought.