Starting a long journey
by DogAngel

Comment:
Beautiful beginning. 10

The Polar Express
by bob637

Comment:
Very nice scenic capture, would get a 10 from me if your steam engine was more detailed but it seems to be lost against the rock. Still a very pretty photography and worth a 7.

Praying at the Altar
by photom

Comment:
Wow what vibrant color and very eye catching. Well done. 10

Shasta Mountain 2
by prbetts

Comment:
Beautiful capture of the snow cap.

Miss you
by LevT

Comment:
Very touching. Made me stop and look. 10 for such power in the presentation.

Cat Scan
by Brad

Comment:
Congrats on the win...but you know that was so cruel to chop up Matt. You should have given him to some toddler and waited a few hours the results would have been amazingly the same with a little dirt added for effect...lol...excellent entry.

one day at a time
by mrsamsa

Comment:

Looking at this it fits the challenge. What I think could improve it is more negative space under the water droplet it just seems too tight at the bottom.

Message edited by HBunch - Removed Critique Club Status.

Some Things Change.... Some Things Don't.
by Gatorguy

Comment:
Critique Club

Fantastic image. Really don't know what I would do to improve it...kinda hard to improve on a first place finish. Well done and congrats on the finishing.

Oh ok only thing that I don't like is the missing foot...oh and that is getting really picky to even come up with that.

Fantastic take on the challenge congrats again.

Anna

Fading Away...
by yael27

Comment:


Very interesting take on the challenge. Fits very well. Only thing I would have done differently is show the base of the candle also. It's questionable as it is if the candles are just staggered or if they really have melted down at different lengths of time.

Anna

Message edited by HBunch - Removed Crit Club status.

Doing Their Duty...
by lizzyc3

Comment:
Critique Club

Nice portrait. Definately meets the challenge. The only real weakness I see in it is I find it slightly softer than I would like to see for a military image. My personal belief is military images need to be crisp and clean with a strong focus rather than the softness. Other than that you have a good portrait going here.

Anna