Bent Shadow (Corollary to "Unbent Shadow" from the "Shadows II" Challenge.)
by GolferDDS

Comment:
pretty darn cool effect, like the BW and composition. almost mind boggling. Very good.

Just Add Breath
by Koriyama

Comment:
Well since it has been validated, you must let me know how you did this; Unless the music is actually on the recorder, please do. Great comp and colors. The framing is the color color but you could have done with out it. Great overall shot.

autumn color arrangements
by kenbo

Comment:
Too much fall brick a brack in this....less is more, oft times. The background provides a nice texture contrast but it is not pleasingly shot in this straght up/down, left/right. you might have chose. It looks like "My Fall Leaf and Seed Collection on Brick' and all that is missing is the little captions stating the name of each item.

Champagne for Two
by EddyG

Comment:
very nice, love the lense flares. The composition is a bit static and the roll of ribbon looks out of place. You might have left the ribbon our all together and moved the berry bowl fron a bit the right glass back a bit which might have improved it or move the right glas back a bit switched the flowers and the berry bowl and move the left glas forward, behind the flowers.. Just a thought. Very good over all shot...and I do hoped you enyoyed the champagne. 7

Wild West Concoction
by backslash

Comment:
Just a bit much, ....too much to look at an I do not understand the focal point. I do like the near monotone look of the shot and the texture contrast....just feel you might have composed btter and picked less here. One suggestion would have been to shoot from the window opoen leftand include the table just underd the top. You would not lose and the antiquity and the shot would just as filled with equipment and still provide some area in which to breath, so to speak. Just a thought. Good overall shot. 6

Just For You
by TerryGee

Comment:
Like the composition very much as well as the lighting. the 'suitor' appears a bit soft in the head, focus wise. other wise very nice. 7

Offering
by space amoeba

Comment:
the line fram is a suitabble color but works to distract me as it melds with the rim of the bowl. I like the composition and perspective very much and the super lighting and overall shot.

Tiny treasures
by wolfen

Comment:
Whilte you made some attempt at composition, I do not feel that what you came up with is the best you might have done. The background is a bit dark but that's OK as it provides some contrast to your subjects and the grain of the wood makes it less static thana plain BG. Feel it could have been lit better , maybe lose the plate as it seems like 'which one does not belong, class' and repositioned the remaing subjects for better comp. 5

horses
by larimarie

Comment:
overkill, the background at the bottom and on the pedestal are really not good, though of the two, the natural color on the pedestal works better against the paneling in the back. Might have considered losing the blue, and all the horses except the two on the natural colored pedestal and used that as you shot.

Wish Bone
by Jacko

Comment:
nice lighting and shot....lose the plate or perhaps a plain plate....the little pattern on the left is distracting....and if yu were to lose the plate, also lose the frame. 7