Bad luck
by Zigomar

Comment:
Looks like you had a great capture. The green tint was a bad choice. Very bad in my opinion. I think that it actually ruined the photo. You had an awesome subject. I like the crop but why why why the green tint????
You should have either stuck with color or gone B&W. Also needs contrast/levels/curves adjustment.
If it wasnt for everything I mentioned, I think this would have been a winner.

White Dog + Punks On Dope
by pawdrix

Comment:
You really caught a great shot here. I dont really care for the white border. Something darker would have brought the subjects together better and a nice vignette would have made them pop.
You really need a levels/curves adjustment as well.
I just love the photo though. It's just not quite there as far as being "finished" IMO
Best of luck to you. Despite everything I mentioned, its one of my favs in the challenge.

October 2008
by e301

Comment:
I would love to see this one in color. I think the B&W might have been a mistake. The painting on the wall looks to be colorful. It would have been a nice contrast. I hope you post the color version after the challenge.
Best of luck, its a great capture.

Rainy Day
by tfarrell23

Comment:
nice capture. A bit too soft for my liking. I think you brought down the Clarity level way too much for the overall shot.

Alone
by dougi555

Comment:
great capture. great color and I like the vignetting, it really helps to bring focus in on the subject.
lighting is really nice as well. 9

waitin' for pub o'clock
by MichaelC

Comment:
great capture. Perhaps a tighter crop would have benefited this photo IMO. The right side is a bit distracting.
It also seems maybe a little too much PP went into the photo? Needs a bit more sharpness as well.
Best of Luck.

Through the Ice Canyon
by BHuseman

Comment:
excellent colors and comp!

The Offering
by sherpet

Comment:
This is still my favorite image out of the challenge. I think it should have made top 3. Top 10 is good though.
1st place in my book though. lol great job and congrats.

Untitled
by citymars

Comment:

Originally posted by colorcarnival: after I read the last comment you received, a word popped into my head that I have not used since grade school: whir-dey... and we used it to put emphasis on all meanings behind the word "DUH". It's too bad that someone could not tell from the image that you had a glowing duck. I'm sure that if you had titled it "duck" that it would have been much clearer and garnered you some more votes. Think about it, man... I do like the simplicity of this photo and the duck has a nice glow about it too.

Obviously you missed the whole point of my comment too. lol

Young Einstein!
by Judi

Comment:
great shot. I would have liked to have seen this with more dramatic lighting. Something a little darker and moody to really pull you in. But I still think it will be top 3 for sure. good luck and great capture