Reflections on a Canal
by sher

Comment by Sonifo:
Are the trees the subject. Not very interesting to look at.

Reflections on a Canal
by sher

Comment by jmsetzler:
this is a good line, but it doesn't 'lead' anywhere important in the photo... the black and white also seems to be a little flat overall... - setzler

Reflections on a Canal
by sher

Comment by kandyj:
Your title hleps explain how this meets the challenge. Nice use of b/w.

Eggclipse
by sher

Comment by dacrazyrn:
Great color, contrast and lighting. 8

A Prize Inside
by sher

Comment by lisae:
Not a very appealing photo. The light is very strong, and it's too tightly cropped. I would like to see it with a wider aperture (if you can control that) because it would give the photo more depth.

Rhythmic Steps
by sher

Comment by Gracious:
Critique Club Comments by Grayce

Sher, This is very eye-catching. The perspective works to lead my eyes throughout the image. I like how it curves up near the top. Very well composed.
The interplay of shadows and light keep it interesting and rythmic.
Adding the gaussian was a very good idea, that contributes to the overall textural effect.
I do wonder if leaving the rusty color in it would have been even better, but black and white works too.
Good job, and I look forward to more of your images.
Regards,

Grayce

A Prize Inside
by sher

Comment by kiwiness:
Nice colours here, you got me feeling hungry now. Originally a 5 but bumped up to an 8 for reasons of hunger :-)

A Prize Inside
by sher

Comment by tcherring:
Very original and a great shot...reminds me of the "good ol days".. I loved it.

A Prize Inside
by sher

Comment by shirleygirl_71373:
The color and texture of this picture are very good

A Prize Inside
by sher

Comment by ChrisW123:
Umm, I love Cracker Jacks.