Puuurdy Pencils
by evmariedogs

Comment by autool:
Composition: Subject Placement, Cropping, Background5,
Technical: Focus, Exposure, Lighting, Processing5,
Challenge: Does your entry meet it?10,
Appeal: Is it Interesting, Motivating, Etc.? 4,
Total Averaged Rating6. Autool

Puuurdy Pencils
by evmariedogs

Comment by syamjonimi:
This definitely fits the challenge. The background color detracts from the brilliance on the pencils.

Puuurdy Pencils
by evmariedogs

Comment by rll07:
'very awesome colors!! nice job on this squirty

Puuurdy Pencils
by evmariedogs

Comment by floyd:
That's a BIG pencil! Nice idea and well executed. Needed perhaps some different lighting to give it a little more pazazz.

Puuurdy Pencils
by evmariedogs

Comment by tee tah:
I don't think the challenge name should be used in the title.

Puuurdy Pencils
by evmariedogs

Comment by Kavey:
What an excellent pencil collection. Interesting layout, but the pink carpet is definitely overshadowing the wonderful colours of the pencils (for me anyway). Nice even lighting across whole lot.
Kavey

Puuurdy Pencils
by evmariedogs

Comment by Journey:
I fail to see what the elaborate line up of the pencils and chalk must convey but I just may not be familiar with it. The middle pencil must be huge if the other pencils are indeed norrmal size. Don't find the color of the background helpful; black would have been much better and stronger. 5 Journey

Puuurdy Pencils
by evmariedogs

Comment by HBunch:
This is very pretty. I would love to see the patterns you went through to get this one. the lighting is great. no distracting shadows or bright spots. I think it would have a slight bit more artistic appeal if you had taken the time to space evenly and arrange colors. There are 2 yellow things down in the bottom left and no other yellow around the circle. In the triangles in the middle, there are 2 yellow erasers in the bottom triangle, and a yellow and a blue eraser in the top triangle. You did a great job of pattern though. Pencil, chalk, pencil, eraser. All the way around. I also like the color of the background. Makes the colors of the chalk, pencils and erasers stand out. Nice job and good luck in the challenge.

Puuurdy Pencils
by evmariedogs

Comment by DougPaz:
Nice, but just a bit too busy for me.

Puuurdy Pencils
by evmariedogs

Comment by drewmedia:
A different color as a background could really make these pencils stand out much more and be much more effective.