Quit Kit
by MelGrahm

Comment by redneckbond:
very interesting picture, and awsome perspective

Quit Kit
by MelGrahm

Comment by Go-KL:
Great use of a panorama shape, very effective in B/W - stretching the proportion theme perhaps (But there again so have 90% of the images)

Quit Kit
by MelGrahm

Comment by hannafate:
What's a quit kit? All I see is a cigarette butt. Your techinique is good, but I don't see the connection to proportion.

It's all a bunch of garbage anyway
by MelGrahm

Comment by HBunch:
Not very creative, but good point. Definately garbage. I like how you have filled the entire photo with the subject. Your focus is great, i can almost read the articles. lighting and colors are also very nice. Technically well done. Good luck in the challenge. ~Hbunch7187~

It's all a bunch of garbage anyway
by MelGrahm

Comment by Ruben:
Geat Concept: "Pregarbage!"

It's all a bunch of garbage anyway
by MelGrahm

Comment by autool:
Composition: Subject Placement, Cropping, Background6,
Technical: Focus, Exposure, Lighting, Processing7,
Appeal: Is it Interesting, Motivating, Etc.? 6,
Total Averaged Rating6. Autool

It's all a bunch of garbage anyway
by MelGrahm

Comment by sanandan:
you are right!

It's all a bunch of garbage anyway
by MelGrahm

Comment by mcrael:
Good creative idea, and well executed.

It's all a bunch of garbage anyway
by MelGrahm

Comment by focus:
You were partially successful in combining several articles to convey your main thought. (The one of what appears to be a fruit salad didn't fit with your theme.) However, your photograph didn't add any artistic value to your statement. The magazines' layouts and pictures carried to whole weight of the presentation. Using alternate (spot) lighting, angles, framing and other features may have added *your* talent and ability to this picture.

It's all a bunch of garbage anyway
by MelGrahm

Comment by goodtempo:
so true