Petal
by welcher

Comment:
This is my only 10 so far. So many people think that a flower, if properly exposed and in focus, makes a wonderful image. That is not true, and in many cases, it is the lighting that sets a great floral image apart from the nice, but boring images. This shot is nearly perfect in lighting, which is so tough to achieve. The range from light to dark tones is very good, without any lown highlights. The lower dark petals offset the bright upper petals in a way that balances your composition. The actual shape of your composition is nothing special, but the lighting really makes it! DOF is great, focus is perfect, lighting is great. the only thing I can find fault in are the two white specks on the left side of the image (in the black background). That's easy to fix for printing, and I won't count off for it due to the restriction on spot editing (this image is a good reason to get rid of that rule). Nice shot, my only 10 so far! Good luck in the challenge!
JD Anderson

Spiraling
by mcmurma

Comment:
OK, so this is really cool. I like your use of props here. Colors are good, too. Nice job. 8 JD Anderson

Repitition in form
by Natasha

Comment:
There are images in the challenge that have more visual appeal than this one, but this is the most clever by far! Did you set this up? Or was it your sharp eye that caught this repeating pattern? either way, I like it a lot. Is that a dress, or fancy pajamas??? If it's fancy underwear/pajamas, then I'd be inclined to think this shot is set up. Either way, I like it! 8 Good luck in the challenge!
JD Anderson

Harmony
by Jean

Comment:
Congrats! My only 10 for this challenge. I thought it was a really cool abstract at first, but I quickly realized it consists of a glass and some plant leaves, on mirror/glass. A very nice set up, very clever and very appealing color and tone. Your focus, DOF, clarity of detail, lighting, etc are all perfect. There appears to be some falloff of DOF from the glass to the leaves, but I like that. I think it helps the photo, rather than having the leaves crisp and sharp. The patterns created in the liquid are wonderful. The only thing I don;t like about this shot is the border you chose. Yes, that color reflects similar colors in the image, but because of that, the border appears very weak and flat to me. The dark green in the leaf on the bottom right might have been a better choiice of color for the border, IMHO. I won't knock your score for a border, though. Everything else is perfect! Great job! 10

JD Anderson

A Kiss ...
by nathaliedoo

Comment:
Very simple, very nice! One of my favorites for this challenge. Reminds me when I went to boot camp in 1983... My girlfriend snet me letters sealed with a kiss! 8

Entrance!
by 3boyzMom

Comment:
Nice colors, nice perspective! I would have given it a 10 if you hadn't cut of the leading edge of the 'e'

Gallery Place-Chinatown
by ClubJuggle

Comment:
The Metro is a really great place for this challenge. I didn't even think of it (and I'm close by). I like that you used black and white on this (the greenish yellow cast in the Metro shots would not have worked as well). Nice angle, you did great with the lighting, which can be very difficult there. The black rectangle in the upper left is a little distracting to me. Overall a fun shot of a fun place!

Flip side
by Jacko

Comment:
What a great shot! composition, focus, lighting, DOF---all are perfect! I'm giving it a 10! One of my favorites (and only 10 so far) this week!

Heat
by Alecia

Comment:
Great image, but I'm not understanding your tie in to perspective. I'm scoring this image based on how much I feel it ties into the challenge, although I feel it would deserve a better score just because it is such a good image. If you can explain your tie in to perspective to me, I will adjust my score accordingly (if I understand and agree). In order to stay anonamous and not violate any rules, you could create a free hotmail account or something like that so I won't know who you are at DPChallenge!

Specks and the Universe
by greenem2

Comment:
I like your take on perspective and this is a great image. I would have cropped it midway through the sand on the bottom. I think this photo would have better balance with the horizon at the bottom third of the photo. I don't thinkyou would loose the expansive feel of the image with respect to the children, even corpped tighter on the bottom.