Dissolution
by Shaurya

Comment:
very good, this was my original idea.

Frank the Cat
by freakin_hilarious

Comment:
too much dark...

Catching colors from the dark sky
by Pascal

Comment:
here I see color on a black a white sky.....I am a physicist and love the space but I amn't secure that the shot match the contest :) 5

...The way to NoWhere...
by Apee

Comment:
I think that is a good idea but I prefer the arrows in the left lower corner.

The Results
by amandalore

Comment:
Hi, I notice this shot during the contest and I assign you an high rating.
I like this shot for many reasons.
1) The composition that I think is perfect
2) The tone of the shot very nice
3) It is perfect for the challenge
4) The light and the shadows that there are. The bit of over exposure on the left side of the woman add a dramatic tone to the image
5) The model is perfect in her pose
6) It is one of the little photos that even if released in a bathroom have good taste and he is not gross indeed it is nearly timid, discreet, intimate.
A very good work.
Best Regards
Gennaro

Side by side.
by Nospeak

Comment:
* Greeting from Critique Club *

I think that here you want a representation of a view of the human progress from the nature point of view.
If I understand your idea I think that is a good idea. I am perplexed about the realization. too dark the plants, they occupy too much space in the frame and too much little occupy the bridge. It result that the photograph is too dark. from compositive point of view I think that you can to raise the machine and obtain two good effects, the first is a smallest dark area in the lower frame and the second is the bridge in the left upper corner without to lose the diagonal of the plant.
Best Regards

Waved perspective
by Simpa

Comment:
* Greetings from Critique Club *

Hi, there are some aspects in this image that I liken't.
1) The noise, too much for obtain a nice image. Under exposure? great crop?
2) The shot is oblique
3) there is a geometrical distortion, this is nice in some photograph but here don't work
4) there isn't a clean subject

I think that the location is good for obtain nice images.
Many auguries for the future releases.
Best Regards
Gennaro

Gallantly Streaming
by jessebradley

Comment:
* Greetings from critique Club *

Hi, write a critique on an image from a contest where the subject are fireworks is very difficult because the traditional evaluation criteria often are by passed.
I think that is a good image, the composition is classic and there aren't overexposure areas. The colours are tenuous and pleasant.
About the frame I prefer a thinner line. the photograph is good in the complex but it lacks an element that the face to notice between the others.
Best Regards
Gennaro

Saving Private Ryan
by judojoe

Comment:
:)

Dog Wanted
by rasdub

Comment:
I think that the idea is very good. The subject of the photograph is the ball and it is out of focus.