60 Years Later, Still So Much Hate
by levyj413

Comment:
Lighting is terrible. Maybe it is meant to be that way, but for me it distracts from the picture.


I am not a good photographer, I do not claim to be better than anyone, any criticism is meant to be constructive criticism......

Why...Did I Enter This?
by Elaine

Comment:
Good question....Not a bad abstract, but....

I am not a good photographer, I do not claim to be better than anyone, any criticism is meant to be constructive criticism......

magic mushroom
by cal_russell

Comment:
To cluttered, confusing and out of focus.

I am not a good photographer, I do not claim to be better than anyone, any criticism is meant to be constructive criticism......

Why do people hate us pyro's?/Why is the flash so bright!
by MightyTimBob

Comment:
Does not appeal to me. Maybe I would like it better with better lighting, but Not enough for it to stand out in my mind. Looks thrown together at the last moment....

I am not a good photographer, I do not claim to be better than anyone, any criticism is meant to be constructive criticism......

Why am I all alone? (The Life of Pi translated)
by higgledy

Comment:
Good contrast of color. I like the location of the flower. The only thing for me is the connection to "Why". That seems to be a case for a lot of the pictures here though.


I am not a good photographer, I do not claim to be better than anyone, any criticism is meant to be constructive criticism......

Question
by katOsu

Comment:
I like it. Not amazing, but very good!

I am not a good photographer, I do not claim to be better than anyone, any criticism is meant to be constructive criticism......

Abandoned.....
by JeniY

Comment:
Maybe I am partial to B&W, but I think this is very good. Very sharp and I feel like asking myself why as well.. 8

I am not a good photographer, I do not claim to be better than anyone, any criticism is meant to be constructive criticism......

water, water, everywhere, why must we pay to drink?
by tate

Comment:
Very well executed. I like it a lot and it asks the question why. I like it 8

I am not a good photographer, I do not claim to be better than anyone, any criticism is meant to be constructive criticism......

Think twice! - Why?
by korpen

Comment:
Very nice. It also fits the challenge well. If I were to make a change, I think I would crop the photo into landscape perspective and cut out some of the water making it the bottom third of the picture and the sky(with the smoke) the top third. I like it a lot though...(I just tried the crop and I am torn as to which I like better)

I am not a good photographer, I do not claim to be better than anyone, any criticism is meant to be constructive criticism......

"Guy, you know WHY..."
by Windtale

Comment:
Very good. Has a lot of depth. I think the only thing that would make it better for me is a thicker frame. Maybe a little less light on the reaching hand. Overall very good. 8

I am not a good photographer, I do not claim to be better than anyone, any criticism is meant to be constructive criticism......