DPChallenge: A Digital Photography Contest You are not logged in. (log in or register
 
Challenge Entries

DQ'd
 
You are viewing the last image.
Portfolio Images
 This image was disqualified from the What's Old Is New Again challenge.
Modern Day Native American
Modern Day Native American
Beaubeau


Photograph Information Photographer's Comments
Challenge: What's Old Is New Again (Standard Editing)
Collection: Portfolio
Camera: Nikon D850
Location: Sarasota FL
Date: Jan 26, 2020
Aperture: 7.1
ISO: 320
Shutter: 1/2000
Date Uploaded: Jan 28, 2020

I went to a Native American festival where young and old were dressed in native clothing. It was interesting to see everyone going back to their heritage.
Disqualification Details
Susan, you have GOT to read the rules. If they aren't clear to you set up a chat with me and I walk you through them. The rules allow you to clone out elements but they have to be replaced with whatever would have been there if the object were not. So you can remove a bush on a hillside but it has to be replaced with the surrounding grass, whatever. Thus kind of wholesale removal of a distracting portion and replacing it with another image is reserved for Extended editing.

Statistics
Views since voting: 354
Views during voting: 85
Comments: 19
Favorites: 0


Please log in or register to add your comments!

AuthorThread
02/12/2020 08:30:58 PM
Originally posted by jomari:

You did a brilliant job with that background/texture. Too bad it didn't pass rules muster.


THANKS SO MUCH. Rules are rules. I知 new to group and learning. Appreciate the comment.
02/12/2020 08:26:01 PM
You did a brilliant job with that background/texture. Too bad it didn't pass rules muster.
02/11/2020 06:44:07 PM
I had a feeling that it would be disqualified, but I always like to give the person the benefit of the doubt. I知 sure you値l be on the front page again very soon :-)
02/11/2020 01:22:44 PM
Originally posted by JakeKurdsjuk:

Originally posted by glad2badad:

Originally posted by Beaubeau:

Originally posted by Neat:

Great photo, I知 wondering if the background is legal? Anyway time will tell.
Thank you. The Background is just a texture but who knows- it was fun to do and i like the shot. The feathers actually looked like that - it's not the texture. I checked back on the original photo. Thanks for your comments.

Interesting. If the background is a "texture" then wouldn't it be applied to the entire image? I'm still unclear on how the whole texture stuff (rules) apply.


Alas the minute I saw this I asked myself the same question about legality and only bring it up hear since it's already been asked. The removal of unwanted objects bullet in the Standard Rules tells me that this is likely not kosher. But I'll say this, it's a brilliant job on the replacement.


Well technically nothing was removed...Texture is applied over the image But thanks for your feedback!
02/11/2020 11:54:43 AM
Originally posted by glad2badad:

Originally posted by Beaubeau:

Originally posted by Neat:

Great photo, I知 wondering if the background is legal? Anyway time will tell.
Thank you. The Background is just a texture but who knows- it was fun to do and i like the shot. The feathers actually looked like that - it's not the texture. I checked back on the original photo. Thanks for your comments.

Interesting. If the background is a "texture" then wouldn't it be applied to the entire image? I'm still unclear on how the whole texture stuff (rules) apply.


Who knows - time will tell but the texture is applied over the background - you don't have to apply texture to the entire image and it doesn't have to be applied at 100% either. The background is underneath the texture -I appreciate your comments though. I'm new to the community but enjoying it. Thanks for the feedback.
02/11/2020 10:07:19 AM
Originally posted by glad2badad:

Originally posted by Beaubeau:

Originally posted by Neat:

Great photo, I知 wondering if the background is legal? Anyway time will tell.
Thank you. The Background is just a texture but who knows- it was fun to do and i like the shot. The feathers actually looked like that - it's not the texture. I checked back on the original photo. Thanks for your comments.

Interesting. If the background is a "texture" then wouldn't it be applied to the entire image? I'm still unclear on how the whole texture stuff (rules) apply.


Alas the minute I saw this I asked myself the same question about legality and only bring it up hear since it's already been asked. The removal of unwanted objects bullet in the Standard Rules tells me that this is likely not kosher. But I'll say this, it's a brilliant job on the replacement.
02/10/2020 07:46:48 AM
Originally posted by Beaubeau:

Originally posted by Neat:

Great photo, I知 wondering if the background is legal? Anyway time will tell.
Thank you. The Background is just a texture but who knows- it was fun to do and i like the shot. The feathers actually looked like that - it's not the texture. I checked back on the original photo. Thanks for your comments.

Interesting. If the background is a "texture" then wouldn't it be applied to the entire image? I'm still unclear on how the whole texture stuff (rules) apply.
02/10/2020 07:19:50 AM
Originally posted by Ammie:

O wow!
He was such a cool subject!
02/10/2020 07:19:22 AM
Originally posted by spencelg:

In my top 4.
thank you!
02/10/2020 07:18:59 AM
Originally posted by ltlmschrisss:

I really like this. Love the lighting and the topic choice. I am not sure about the painting texture to cover the background (rules wise). It also got a little too blended into his headdress.

Actually that is the discoloration of the feather. The background is a texture - but I guess it will be up to the rules people. I like the shot and thanks for your comments.
02/10/2020 07:17:27 AM
Originally posted by Art Roflmao:

Originally posted by Art Roflmao:

Did he get that blanket from the British?
Too soon? ;-)

Congrats on the top 5 finish! Very well done.

Thank you - not sure about the blanket!~
02/10/2020 07:16:56 AM
Originally posted by Neat:

Great photo, I知 wondering if the background is legal? Anyway time will tell.
Thank you. The Background is just a texture but who knows- it was fun to do and i like the shot. The feathers actually looked like that - it's not the texture. I checked back on the original photo. Thanks for your comments.
02/10/2020 03:23:35 AM
Great photo, I知 wondering if the background is legal? Anyway time will tell.
02/10/2020 01:16:03 AM
Originally posted by Art Roflmao:

Did he get that blanket from the British?
Too soon? ;-)

Congrats on the top 5 finish! Very well done.
 Comments Made During the Challenge
02/09/2020 11:15:52 PM
Lovely shot.
02/09/2020 09:45:42 PM
I really like this. Love the lighting and the topic choice. I am not sure about the painting texture to cover the background (rules wise). It also got a little too blended into his headdress.
02/09/2020 01:55:31 PM
In my top 4.
02/09/2020 12:37:00 AM
Did he get that blanket from the British?
02/03/2020 12:56:04 AM
O wow!


Home - Challenges - Community - League - Photos - Cameras - Lenses - Learn - Prints! - Help - Terms of Use - Privacy - Top ^
DPChallenge, and website content and design, Copyright © 2001-2020 Challenging Technologies, LLC.
All digital photo copyrights belong to the photographers and may not be used without permission.
Proudly hosted by Sargasso Networks. Current Server Time: 10/30/2020 10:00:51 PM EDT.