Soul Centering
by jenesis

Comment:
Lovely shot, great composition

A competitive spirit
by bcenu

Comment:
The image is well executed and I like the way the lighting fades to a proper black behind the figure. I don't think the POV is particularly flattering as there's no face-to-face contact for the viewer. The use of the reflective surface just mirrors this rather uninteresting view. The tight crop doesn't help either.

I think your scores indicate that there were few people who loved it and few who hated it.

Why am I white......when everyone else is yellow?
by SEG

Comment:
I also thought it was a bit of a shoehorn, and only really worked because of the title. I don't find it puzzling.

However, it has great selective focus and exposure and the colours are vivid. The border detracts rather than adds.

Who's Watching the Watchers..?
by rob_smith

Comment:

Originally posted by glad2badad: As a follow-up to the thread you opened I'd thought I'd comment... Technically it may be a "camera", but c'mon...this is a photography site, what did you expect? I for one, anticipated regular cameras, you know the kind used for photography; not movies or videos. If you do decide to go outside the anticipated box, then the image needs to be unique and interesting, not a snapshot-ish type of image. During voting I gave this a generous 4. All JMO of course. :-)

The challenge description specifically details 'any camera'. Seems to me you were robbed, Rob.

Pieces of an Apple
by Lydia

Comment:
You have obviously put a lot of thought and effort into this. Nice lighting and colours.

Find the key to unlock the puzzle
by Giorgio

Comment:
Beautiful processing and a really interesting image.

What Next?
by JustinM

Comment:
I'm afraid that without the title this image wouldn't meet the challenge.

However, good lighting and a nicely composed photo.

Solid liquid
by marbo

Comment:
This is very like the Macro puzzle entries but seems to have less 'punch' than before.

The Final Piece
by M_Jayne

Comment:
I love the lighting on this, giving it an almost spiritual feel. I get the feeling that when that puzzle is complete ANYTHING could happen.

masta of disastah
by goc

Comment:
Whilst the presence of a toilet in a forest is puzzling, I don't think the image has the necessary 'punch' to make the point.