Fake Rolex
by alanfreed

Comment:
I feel that this image needs a bit of softness to take some of harshness that is in the relfective surface of the watch and might obscure some of what I see as noise in this image.

Other then that, I like the composition of the image, the placement of the "Rolex" is nice and shows it off nicely.

Extreme Ironing
by xtabintun

Comment:
This is fantasticly hilarious!

I love the sharpness and the 'Extreme' look in the subject's face. Good luck and keep shooting these humorous images.

CRW_8830.jpg
by BikeRacer

Comment:
Why do I think 'Jabba the Hutt' when I gaze upon this little guy?

Excellent shot by the way.

Mr. Trooper, the substitute teacher, always freaked me out.
by thommo

Comment:
I don't think he is as freaky as say... Mr. Vader the Substitute Principal is...

Great idea, funny and cool.

Self-Censored
by annasense

Comment:
I don't quite see how this is much of a political statement or much of a social statement. If you had perhaps held the 'Modest(y)' sign vertically to the left of the photo, revealing it all, so to speak, the shot, in my opinion, would take on a greater political and or social commentary meaning.

As it stands, the image provides little more then a statement of the American Status Quo. It is an affirmation of that which already exists in American Society. There is no challenge to my American values in this image.

That being said, the image is quite nicely captured and post processed. Based on the 'Nude II' topic challenge, I personally would have scored this a 9. I really like that amount that has been captured in the image, the slight tilt of your head, the slight grain to the image, the background. To me, it is a very well composed image.

I like this image.

Downtown Diner
by L1

Comment:
I like the 'grit' of the city you capture in this image. The angle is very nice as well. You chose a good time to go and shoot this neon sign. I am fairly sure this wouldn't have had the same impact on me if shot at night.

Green River (Water Chestnuts)
by Neil

Comment:
This is a nice landscape photo. I would play with the blue levels a bit to bring the sky a more attractive blue tone. I like the vibrancy of the green as well. This is a decent landscape shot that I could see in a magazine, book and possibly hanging in someone's home.

Unfortunately, I am unable to see what plant life is the primary subject of this image, which takes it out of the context of the challenge. Is it the tree that is cut off on the right and top of the image? Is it the grass? The bushes?

Because of the lack of a clear central subject, such as a single type of plant clearly dominating the image, like a field of the same type of flower or plant shot tight enough to exclude most everything else from the image, I am unable to score this image very high.

Knee On Lights
by GeneralE

Comment:
Great concept, it;s just unfortunate that the shot isn't perfectly in focus. The lighting seems a bit off as well. The world needs more people that think outside the box like this.

I wish I could tell you how to fix up this shot, if you were looking to reshoot it. All I know is that there would be a bunch of experimenting.

N. Tetra
by photom

Comment:
Very nice capture, it also a very interesting angle that you have here. Keep this line of thinking up. Nice capture of the fish.

Ne 20.180
by cooliak

Comment:
Very unique take on this challenge. Hitting the Periodic Table of Elements is an excellent choice. I also like the use of the highlighter to bring out the subject.

Great shot, nice DOF use as well.